BroadStreet Partners

BroadStreet Partners is an insurance brokerage holding company based in Columbus, Ohio, that invests in entrepreneurial, high-performing independent insurance agencies across the United States and Canada. Founded in 2001 by Rick Miley, the firm operates through a co-ownership model that lets Core Agency Partners retain operational control while gaining access to capital, acquisition support, and a network of industry expertise. The company ranks among the top private brokerages in North America.

Website: broadstreetcorp.com

Head office address: 580 North 4th Street, Suite 560, Columbus, Ohio 43215

Founded: 2001

Founder: Rick Miley

Company type: privately held insurance brokerage holding company

Investors: Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan (co-control); Ethos Capital, BCI, and White Mountains Insurance Group (ownership stake, 2025)

Business focus: co-ownership investment in independent insurance agencies; middle-market commercial and personal P&C and employee benefits

Regions served: all 50 US states and all 10 Canadian provinces

History of BroadStreet Partners

Rick Miley founded BroadStreet Partners in 2001 with a vision to build a different kind of insurance brokerage — one that partnered with agency owners rather than simply acquiring them. The co-ownership model he developed gives Core Agency Partners an equity stake in their own businesses while the firm provides the capital and infrastructure to support growth and succession. Key milestones include:

  • 2001: Rick Miley founds BroadStreet Partners in Columbus, Ohio
  • 2012: Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan acquires a majority stake, providing capital for accelerated growth
  • 2013: the firm expands its Core Agency Partner network west of the Mississippi River
  • 2017: the company appoints a new president to lead continued geographic expansion
  • 2021: CEO succession implemented; Miley transitions to Executive Chairman
  • 2022: Mike O’Connor joins as president, bringing 12 years of experience from Aon
  • 2023: O’Connor named CEO; Westland Insurance Group joins as a partner, extending the network into all 10 Canadian provinces
  • 2025: Ethos Capital, BCI, and White Mountains Insurance Group acquire an ownership stake; Ontario Teachers’ retains co-control, closing in July 2025
  • 2026: BroadStreet appoints a new board chair with deep financial services and governance experience

Over more than two decades, the firm has grown from a regional Ohio-based operation into a national platform. Its Core Agency Partners have completed more than 450 tuck-in acquisitions, and the company has recorded a 28 percent compound annual revenue growth rate since founding.

How BroadStreet Partners works

The company invests in select independent agencies rather than absorbing them into a single brand. Each Core Agency Partner retains its name, its leadership team, and day-to-day operational control. In return, the partner gains equity participation, capital for acquisitions, and access to BroadStreet’s network of resources. Core capabilities the firm provides to its partners include:

  • capital and financial backing for organic and acquisitive growth
  • M&A support, including legal, accounting, and due diligence expertise
  • access to a network of agency leaders and insurance market relationships
  • risk management, analytics, and capital markets resources
  • tools and expertise for ownership succession planning

The firm focuses on middle-market commercial property and casualty insurance, personal lines, and employee benefits. As of 2025, BroadStreet operates with 30 Core Agency Partners across more than 300 offices, with 800-plus agency professionals holding equity in their local businesses.

BroadStreet Partners in the market

The firm competes in the insurance brokerage consolidation market, where a growing number of platforms are acquiring independent agencies. Its co-ownership model sets it apart from traditional acquirers: partners keep their agency identity and benefit financially from the growth they generate.

The company led all US brokerage buyers in acquisition activity through the third quarter of 2025, having completed 57 transactions — 44 percent above its five-year average. Combined revenue across its Core Agency Partners has reached $2 billion or more. The 2025 investment by Ethos Capital, BCI, and White Mountains Insurance Group, alongside Ontario Teachers’ continuing co-control stake, is expected to support BroadStreet’s next phase of technology investment and geographic expansion.

In the news

Inszone snaps up century-old Tulsa agency in August deal run

MERGERS & ACQUISITIONS

Inszone snaps up century-old Tulsa agency in August deal run

Harris Insurance vetted Inszone through five peer references before agreeing to sell. Retiring owners are doing more homework - and platforms that pass that test are winning more of the available deals

Inszone buys D.B. Insurance in slower market

MERGERS & ACQUISITIONS

Inszone buys D.B. Insurance in slower market

Two consecutive Inszone personal lines acquisitions have the same asset at their core: a referral network that sits at the point of a home deal. That is not coincidence

Kentucky family agency sale shows deal prices holding firm

MERGERS & ACQUISITIONS

Kentucky family agency sale shows deal prices holding firm

Buyers are shrinking in number

Inszone Insurance acquires Bay Area commercial specialist Two Fong's

MERGERS & ACQUISITIONS

Inszone Insurance acquires Bay Area commercial specialist Two Fong's

The deal brings a Bay Area agency known for commercial property and lessor's risk coverage into Inszone's national platform

Insurance moves: AIQA, Crawford, Old Republic, Inszone

INSURANCE NEWS

Insurance moves: AIQA, Crawford, Old Republic, Inszone

One in five insureds has already filed an AI-related claim

Keep up with the latest news and events

Join our mailing list, it’s free!