Among retirement plan participants who never logged in, never read a projection, and never adjusted their contributions, savings rates still improved four times more in behaviorally designed plans than in traditional ones. That is the headline finding of a retrospective analysis by Voya Financial’s Behavioral Finance Institute for Innovation, which examined outcomes among 310,931 participants across 877 plans it administered between December 2017 and June 2026.
The study found that participants in behaviorally informed plans, defined as those using automatic enrollment and automatic escalation, improved their average savings rate by 3.33 percentage points over the period, compared with 1.64 points in traditional plans. Plans combining both automatic features produced the strongest result, a 3.56-point improvement, more than double the traditional plan gain.
Among non-digitally engaged participants in traditional plans, savings rates improved by just 0.99 percentage points. In plans with both automatic enrollment and automatic escalation, the same disengaged group improved by 4.09 points, four times the gain. The plan did the work the participant never did.
Only 57% of employers currently use auto-enrollment and only 33% use auto-escalation, according to Gallagher’s 2026 US Benefits Strategy and Benchmarking Survey of 3,717 organizations. Just 28% of employees, meanwhile, believe their current savings strategy will get them to retirement, even as the majority of their employers offer a retirement plan.
The Voya data offers one explanation for why access and outcomes keep diverging: the design of the plan, rather than just its existence, determines whether employees who never take action still make progress.
For participants who did engage digitally, the combination of behavioral plan design and active use produced the strongest results. Digitally engaged participants in behaviorally informed plans reached average savings rates above 11% of pay by 2026 and grew account balances by 234% over the study period, compared with 201% for digitally engaged participants in traditional plans. Voya notes that market returns contributed to balance growth in both groups, so those figures should not be read as purely a product of plan design.
Digital engagement itself grew over the period, rising from 57.5% of participants in 2017 to 76.1% by 2026, with the highest rates in plans that paired automatic enrollment with automatic escalation.
“People shouldn’t have to think about retirement every day to keep making progress toward it,” said Tom Armstrong, vice president of customer analytics and head of Voya’s Behavioral Finance Institute for Innovation. Voya’s next research phase will examine how AI-enabled personalization can extend behavioral science into more individualized guidance.
SECURE 2.0 already mandates automatic enrollment for most new retirement plans. Vanguard’s 2026 How America Saves data found that 38% of auto-enrollment plans still set starting contributions below 4%. For plan sponsors working through a design review, that starting rate is where auto-escalation either compounds meaningfully over time or does not.