Brokers need to be extremely careful when changing casualty towers: Hartford E&S leader

Navigators’ Lynanne St. Denis explains how a switch to an admitted carrier can change what umbrella and excess insurers will pay
Brokers need to be extremely careful when changing casualty towers: Hartford E&S leader
EXCESS AND SURPLUS
By Gia Snape
Nov 17, 2026

Brokers deciding at renewal whether to move a client’s primary casualty policy out of the excess and surplus (E&S) lines market and into a returning admitted carrier face a question that the primary quote alone won’t answer: will the umbrella and excess layers above it still respond the same way?

That is the warning from Lynanne St. Denis (pictured), head of wholesale property & casualty at Navigators, a brand of The Hartford, the Hartford, Connecticut-based carrier.

As admitted capacity flows back into lines that spent the hard market in E&S, she said brokers restructuring layered programs need to confirm that the new primary policy still fits the tower built on top of it.

“Brokers need to be extremely careful when they’re moving around pieces of a layered program,” St. Denis told Insurance Business. “If you are changing the primary part of the program, moving it to a different carrier, or from a non-admitted carrier to an admitted carrier, you have to be careful that the definitions and the exclusions are aligned with what’s provided in the umbrella and excess, that there’s cohesiveness there.”

Why more brokers face this decision heading into 2027

The decision is becoming more common because the capacity picture has changed. St. Denis described E&S growth as “strong but is normalizing.”

“The shift that we’ve seen over the last year is that capacity has really flowed back (to the admitted market),” she said. “There are a lot of new entrants, startup carriers and MGAs, and that’s created abundant capacity in the admitted market and even more capacity in the non-admitted market as well.”

Read more: Admitted carriers want E&S business – will they stay for renewal?

Premises and and products liability, along with simpler construction risks, are among the classes returning to admitted carriers; these are the kinds of primary general liability placements where a carrier switch is likely to come up at renewal. However, transportation, more complex construction projects and harder-to-place premises risks such as habitational accounts are still firmly in E&S.

Umbrella coverage remains challenging to place. The Council of Insurance Agents & Brokers reported that umbrella premiums rose 5.3% on average in the second quarter, the 35th consecutive quarterly increase. Forty percent of respondents reported less umbrella capacity, and the Council cited large verdicts from commercial auto accidents as a major factor. In the third quarter, average premiums across all account sizes fell 1.3%, while commercial auto premiums rose 6.7%

“On the casualty side, the loss trends driven by legal system abuse and nuclear verdicts haven’t changed,” said St. Denis. “So, we have to be hyper-aware of the quality of risk.”

Sublimits can break a casualty tower

St. Denis’s most specific concern is sublimits. These are caps that limit a particular coverage to less than the policy’s full limit. A coverage can appear in a new primary policy, but whether it carries up into the excess layers is a separate question.

“There are terms within a primary policy where a broker and a customer need to be really careful they’re not imposing gaps in coverage between those primary and excess layers,” she said.

In practice, that means reading the new primary form against the umbrella and excess wording, rather than comparing limits and premium alone.

Read more: Surplus lines hit $143bn record as placement market shifts

Where capacity is tight, St. Denis said brokers can strengthen submissions by showing how clients act on the risks identified in their loss and exposure data. In transportation, where telematics is already commonplace, an underwriter wants to know whether a fleet operator follows up when the data shows a driver repeatedly speeding or braking aggressively, and what it does to improve those driving habits.

“A lot of it is that story around risk mitigation and safety,” St. Denis said. “While it’s important to have all the numerical data, the exposures and the losses, we want to get a sense of how the individual insured operates.

“We want to see that they’re investing in their own risk mitigation, that they’re not simply laying off all that risk. While we are here to provide a backstop for that risk, we want to see that sort of attention, care and investment in safety across their operations.”

Related Stories
Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB US.