Insurance M&A failure starts long before the deal closes

Deals that disappoint share a pattern – and it has nothing to do with price
Insurance M&A failure starts long before the deal closes
MERGERS & ACQUISITIONS
By Roxanne San Jose
Nov 20, 2026

Between 70% and 75% of insurance mergers and acquisitions fail to deliver the value they set out to create – a failure rate that holds across sectors, geographies, and deal sizes, according to new research released November 19, 2026, by management consultancy Oxbow Partners and InsurTech NY.

The study, Getting Insurance M&A Right, is based on an analysis of 333 publicly traded insurance carriers across North America, Europe, and Asia-Pacific, drawing on S&P Capital IQ data covering 1,141 completed acquisitions between 2010 and 2025. The researchers interviewed executives and dealmakers involved in major insurance transactions to identify where, specifically, the value goes missing.

Their conclusion: the gap between what a deal promises and what it delivers is rarely a function of price alone. It almost always traces back to decisions – or the absence of them – made well before the transaction closes.

Read more: Insurance agency M&A sinks to eight-year low as PE exits loom

Serial vs. occasional acquirers

The research segments carriers into inactive, occasional, and serial acquirers and tracks their returns from 2010 to 2025. Serial acquirers – those that treat acquisition as a repeatable discipline rather than a periodic event – delivered significantly higher total shareholder return across the period than occasional buyers. Occasional buyers, in turn, outperformed those that made no acquisitions at all.

Manmeet Singh Bawa, partner at Oxbow Partners in New York, said the evidence points to preparation as the differentiating factor.

“Acquisitions can give insurers access to new markets, capabilities and sources of growth, but completing a transaction is only the beginning. The real test is whether the organization can translate the deal thesis into measurable value,” Bawa said.

He added: “The evidence shows the importance of experience and preparation. Insurers that build their M&A capability before they need it put themselves in a much stronger position when the right opportunity appears.”

Seven points where deals go wrong

The research identifies seven recurring failure points across the deal lifecycle.

The first is a missing or retrofitted strategic rationale. Because most insurance carrier acquisitions are episodic, acquirers often enter a process and work backward to justify the transaction. Auction pressure compounds the problem, shifting attention from whether the deal should happen to whether it can be completed.

The second is due diligence. Compressed timelines were cited as a consistent obstacle. One executive in the report, identified as a head of corporate development involved in a specialty managing general agent (MGA) platform acquisition, said that failure to challenge sell-side figures cost the buyer approximately $100 million in overpayment.

The remaining five challenges span: designing integration before closing rather than after; managing culture and talent; communicating clearly with all stakeholders from the point of announcement; building dedicated integration leadership rather than adding it to existing roles; and tracking post-close value creation against defined metrics before the original deal thesis drifts out of view.

Integration under pressure in a consolidating market

The report’s findings land in a market where integration quality is under greater scrutiny than at any point in recent years. In 2025, there were 854 insurance brokerage transactions in the US, with private capital-backed buyers accounting for 70.8% of that activity, according to MarshBerry’s 2025 Year in Review. The pace has since slowed, with OPTIS Partners recording the slowest start to any year since 2016 through the first half of 2026.

As deal volume moderates, those that completed large volumes of acquisitions during the high-activity years are now contending with the integration work deferred during that period. Deloitte’s 2026 insurance M&A outlook notes that brokerage M&A is shifting toward operational integration, simplification, and targeted tuck-in acquisitions – a direct reflection of platforms working through what they already own.

For brokers, that dynamic has practical consequences. When a carrier or distribution partner is acquired and integration stalls, the effects show up in underwriting appetite shifts, service disruptions, and the departure of underwriters whose relationships with brokers represent real commercial value. The Oxbow Partners report is specific on this point: in specialty lines, underwriter judgment and broker relationships are primary value drivers, making culture and talent management a commercial issue, not simply an organizational one.

Building the capability before the opportunity

The report’s core argument is that M&A readiness must be built between deals, not during them. That means developing defined acquisition criteria, standing market-scanning capability, repeatable integration frameworks, and value-tracking discipline before any specific transaction appears.

Read more: Brokerage deals now have to deliver more than scale: Sunstar CEO

For carriers that have acquired infrequently, the message is not to avoid M&A – it is to invest in the capability that makes acquisitions work. Those that have done so consistently have outperformed. Those that have not carry a structural disadvantage into every deal they attempt.

Related Stories
Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB US.