Allstate’s $700K auto award reversed – bad faith claim lives on

A jury said $700K. The appeals court wanted to see the math
Allstate’s $700K auto award reversed – bad faith claim lives on
RISK, COMPLIANCE & LEGAL
By Regielyn Santiago
Nov 20, 2026

What happened: Florida appeals court reversed a $700,000 medical expenses award, finding the evidence supported roughly $134,000 

Who’s involved: Allstate Fire and Casualty Insurance Company, a defendant driver 

What’s at stake: $700,000 jury award for a child’s auto accident injuries, reduced on appeal 

Why it matters: Claims teams get a hard benchmark on proving future medical expenses are “reasonably certain” 

Where it stands: Reversed and remanded for a reduced award; bad faith pathway against Allstate preserved 

 

A jury awarded a ten-year-old $700,000 for car crash injuries. A Florida appeals court reversed, saying the evidence didn’t add up. 

The Fourth District Court of Appeal found the trial court should have ordered a reduction because testimony could not justify the amount. But in a split outcome, the court kept intact language preserving a pathway for a bad faith claim against Allstate Fire and Casualty Insurance Company. 

Two crashes, one trial 

The child was riding in her father’s car in February 2018 when it collided with a truck. Months later, she was in a second crash. Claims from that second accident were resolved before trial – this case dealt only with the first. 

A treating physician cleared her by July 2018, saying she did not need aggressive treatment. A neurosurgeon, still treating her at trial, testified she might one day need spinal disc surgery – with a hospital stay running $90,000 to $100,000 and the procedure itself costing $25,000 to $30,000. 

At trial, her side put past medical bills at $47,573.88 and future medical expenses at $106,500. No dollar figure was given for other future care. The total ask, including pain and suffering projected over 70 years, was $1,834,073.88. 

The jury found both the driver and the child’s father at fault – 30% and 70% respectively. It awarded $700,000 in medical expenses and $10,000 for pain and suffering. 

$700,000 without the proof 

The appeals court found the medical expenses figure could not stand. Under Florida law, future medical costs must be “reasonably certain to be incurred” –  and testimony that treatments “might possibly” be needed does not clear that bar. The court concluded the evidence supported, at most, $47,573.88 in past bills and about $86,000 for potential future surgery. 

That left most of the $700,000 without evidentiary backing. 

The case goes back to the trial court to reduce the award. If the child’s side rejects the lower figure, a new trial can be limited to medical expenses alone. 

The door Allstate can’t close 

On a second issue, Allstate argued the final judgment went too far. The judgment capped the insurer’s liability at its $25,000 policy limit but preserved the child’s right to bring a bad faith claim for the full amount. Allstate pointed to a recent Second District ruling where similar language had been struck down. 

The appeals court distinguished that case. There, new claims had been filed against the insurer the day after judgment. Here, no new claims were added – the judgment simply noted that future rights were not foreclosed. The court affirmed. 

For claims professionals managing low-limit auto policies on high-exposure injury files, the decision draws a clear line on what counts as proven future medical costs – while confirming that a reduced verdict does not close the book on bad faith. 

The ruling is not final pending disposition of any timely filed motion for rehearing. 

Related Stories
Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB US.