Spokane devastation pressures Washington’s burdened homeowners' insurance market

Broker warns restrictions may leave families facing higher recovery costs

Spokane devastation pressures Washington’s burdened homeowners' insurance market

Property

By Gia Snape

Washington's destructive wildfire outbreak is expected to intensify scrutiny of homeowners' insurance availability, policy restrictions and rebuilding protection as tens of thousands of residents assess whether their properties survived.

The fires broke out Saturday, Aug. 1, prompting Gov. Bob Ferguson to declare a statewide emergency and impose a burn ban. As of Aug. 3, around 65,000 people had been ordered to evacuate parts of the state after multiple fires spread rapidly through the Spokane area, destroying approximately 700 buildings and leaving thousands of homes without electricity.

No deaths had been confirmed, though officials said a small number of people flagged during evacuation efforts had not yet been reached, without necessarily meaning they were missing.

Three major fires near Spokane — Old Trails, Fairview and Autumn Lane — have been grouped together as the Spokane Complex Fires. Strong winds and unusually dry conditions helped push flames across the Spokane River, while officials warned that the fires remained uncontained.

Broker warns policy limits could complicate recovery

Rob Karl (pictured), unit leader for the West Division of World Insurance Associates in Seattle, said clients were confronting both immediate displacement and uncertainty over the condition of their properties.

"It's been a very emotional time," Karl said. "Many folks are grieving and still processing the devastation as families are learning of what's happened to their home or the home of someone they know."

Power outages have added another layer of disruption. Karl said some houses that escaped direct fire damage may still be temporarily uninhabitable because utilities have been shut down.

"There is also a great deal of uncertainty about what to do next," he said. "Parts of Spokane have had the power turned off and so even homes untouched by a fire may not be habitable at this time."

Among the most pressing questions facing affected residents are whether their homes remain standing and where they will live if the properties have been destroyed. Those questions may be complicated by changes insurers have made to wildfire coverage and underwriting in recent years.

Karl said carriers have sought to reduce capacity in wildfire-exposed areas and increasingly require homeowners to take mitigation measures as a condition of continued coverage. "Many policies now have coverage caps that limit the amount that can be paid out in the event of a wildfire if these steps have not been taken," he said.

Insurers have also restricted some additional coverages that can become critical after a disaster, including loss of use protection, which can help pay for temporary accommodation and other living expenses when a home cannot be occupied.

Accommodation shortages may make displacement particularly challenging. With hotels in and around Spokane already filling, some households may have to relocate outside the city, creating secondary challenges involving childcare, commuting and whether children can return to their usual schools in the fall.

It may take months before the insurance industry gains a clearer picture of whether homeowners carried sufficient limits to rebuild, particularly as labor, materials and temporary housing demand rise following the fires. Formal insured loss estimates had not yet been released as of publication.

The scale of this event already dwarfs recent regional precedent: the 2023 Gray Fire, which also burned near Spokane, destroyed 240 structures and caused an estimated $60 million in damage - roughly a third of the structure count already confirmed in the current outbreak.

"Given this has unfortunately become a regular occurrence year over year, the hope is that folks have planned for these types of events and secured coverage in case the worst happens," Karl said. "We will not know for some time if that is in fact the case."

Coverage moratoriums halt new business

Insurers have already imposed moratoriums on new homeowners' policies in affected locations, a common step when an active catastrophe is threatening properties. Karl warned that the restrictions could also disrupt real estate transactions if buyers cannot secure insurance for homes that survived the fires.

The longer-term effect on Washington pricing and capacity will depend on the ultimate insured loss, as well as the cost of other catastrophes during the remainder of the year. "It might take a few years for the carriers to assess the extent of the financial impact from the losses as they reevaluate rates for Washington," Karl said. "This increased cost to the carrier will drive rates up for all insureds whether they are in a wildfire zone or not." He also noted that reinsurance costs could influence future premiums. 

The losses could also push carriers to become more selective in areas with significant wildfire exposure. According to Washington's Office of the Insurance Commissioner, the number of homeowners nonrenewed or canceled by their insurer has doubled since 2021, growing from 11,763 to 24,106, with Commissioner Patty Kuderer saying she repeatedly heard from homeowners who held a policy for decades before receiving a sudden nonrenewal notice. Homeowners in forested areas around Leavenworth and Chelan County have reported being dropped despite long claim-free histories, with some shifting to surplus lines carriers or the state's FAIR Plan when standard coverage becomes unavailable.

With damage assessments still underway and containment not yet achieved as of early August, the coming weeks are likely to bring clearer figures on insured losses, as well more detail on how carriers are drawing coverage boundaries.

Related Stories

Keep up with the latest news and events

Join our mailing list, it’s free!