Property insurance brokers are losing new-business pipeline at both ends – fewer renters are converting to homeowners, and the states gaining the most new residents are the hardest in which to place residential coverage. A new TransUnion analysis, published November 17, 2026, puts a number on that contraction: the renter-to-homeowner conversion rate dropped from 7.2% in 2009 to 3.9% in 2025, a decline of 46%, according to TransUnion’s 2027 Personal and Commercial Lines Annual Insurance Outlook, a forward-looking annual report covering the year ahead.
Texas, Florida, North Carolina, South Carolina, and Tennessee recorded the highest inbound migration rates in the country, according to the report. All five carry elevated exposure to hurricanes and severe convective storms relative to the states residents are leaving.
“There is potential for growth in the property insurance space for insurers that can accurately segment high-value renters and homeowners. However, the migration trends we’re seeing suggest that much of that growth is inextricably tied to elevated risks from climate change,” said Patrick Foy, senior director of strategic planning for TransUnion’s insurance business in Chicago.
Brokers working high-migration markets are already navigating what that tension looks like in practice, as explored in Insurance Business America’s coverage of how Florida’s property market has shifted and what it means for brokers.
Read more: Florida’s property market has shifted – what brokers need to know
The affordability side of this equation adds further pressure. The Insurance Information Institute (Triple-I) launched its Insurance Affordability Index on September 2, 2026, measuring insurance costs against median household income in every state. The index – available on the Triple-I website – shows homeowners insurance consumed an estimated 2.4% of median household income nationally in 2025, up 24% from 2020. That cost burden shapes which risks brokers can realistically place, and at what premium, in markets already stretched for available carrier capacity.
According to the US Census Bureau’s Q3 2025 Housing Vacancies and Homeownership report, the US homeownership rate stood at 65.3% – still below its 25-year average of 66.3% and down from a peak of 69.2% in 2004. With fewer renters crossing into homeownership and housing affordability at multi-decade lows, the new-client pipeline that has historically driven personal lines book growth is narrowing.
Foy noted that retaining existing clients has become as commercially important as new-client acquisition. “The best way to keep business is to deepen the relationship by cross-selling coverage that meets consumers’ evolving needs,” he said. For brokers in high-migration states, that means proactively reviewing existing homeowners clients for coverage gaps, confirming whether the carrier writing those policies still has appetite in that state, and identifying which renter clients are most likely to convert so they can be positioned for homeowners coverage before they reach the market.
The TransUnion report identifies the small commercial segment as a growth opportunity – one with a constraint that currently favors brokers over direct digital channels.
Small business applications have exceeded 400,000 per month for five consecutive years, with volume trending above 500,000 since late 2025, according to the report. TransUnion finds that 83% of small business owners prefer to shop for insurance through online channels – but fewer than one in three actually do so. The gap is attributed to a shortfall in digital purchasing infrastructure among commercial carriers, not a lack of demand.
“Small business owners are consumers first, and they are accustomed to great customer experiences through digital channels in every area of their lives. That’s why it’s so jarring and disappointing for them to find that missing when they shop for small business insurance. The insurers that can close that gap are going to win,” said Scott Learn, advisor for commercial insurance strategic planning at TransUnion in Chicago.
The Independent Insurance Agents & Brokers of America (IIABA) – commonly referred to as the Big “I” – confirmed in its 2026 Market Share Report that independent agents wrote 87.7% of commercial lines written premiums in 2025, a share that has held steady even as personal lines shifted toward direct channels. Small commercial clients who cannot find a seamless digital-buying experience remain broker-dependent – giving agents an opening to cross-sell from existing personal lines relationships before carriers close that gap. The dynamics behind that shift are examined in Insurance Business America’s analysis of how commercial carriers are turning digital distribution into a retention advantage.
Read more: How commercial carriers are turning digital distribution into a retention advantage
The trucking sector’s demographic profile is adding underwriting pressure to an already strained line of business – and brokers placing commercial auto need to get ahead of it.
The average commercial truck driver is now 47 years old, according to TransUnion. Baby Boomers account for more than 20% of the driver population, while Gen Z represents less than 10%. As older drivers retire, their replacements are younger and less experienced, compounding pressure on a line that posted a confirmed $2.2 billion underwriting loss in 2025 – a 55% improvement on 2024, according to AM Best’s November 2026 commercial auto market segment report. Data from the American Transportation Research Institute (ATRI) shows average trucking insurance premiums rose 8.3% annually between 2017 and 2025, more than double the general inflation rate over that period.
Elevated diesel prices are adding further strain, squeezing owner-operators and small fleets and limiting their capacity to maintain vehicles and retain drivers. The broader context facing trucking brokers is covered in Insurance Business America’s report on why commercial trucking is bracing for more volatility. At renewal, brokers working trucking and fleet accounts should expect underwriters to scrutinize driver age distribution, equipment age, and telematics data closely – and should prepare clients to present loss control documentation before underwriters ask for it.