What happened: A truck driver’s comp claim after a 2020 rear-end collision was denied - the Commission found no compensable injury.
Who’s involved: Warren Paving Inc. (employer) and Zurich American Insurance Company (carrier).
What’s at stake: Over two years of temporary total disability benefits and the cost of a permanent spinal cord stimulator.
Why it matters: Dashcam footage and pre-existing medical records gave the carrier the evidence to overturn a ruling that initially went the driver’s way.
Where it stands: Mississippi Court of Appeals affirmed the denial 6-3 on November 17, 2026.
Three days before his 18-wheeler was rear-ended on a Mississippi highway, the driver was already in the emergency room for the same back pain.
The driver was hauling asphalt for Warren Paving on August 11, 2020, when a pickup rear-ended his rig. He jumped out to check on the other driver. His truck needed minor repairs and still finished the delivery.
Then there was the dashcam.
Inside-the-cab footage showed him holding his cell phone at the moment of impact. He did not drop it. A water bottle on the passenger seat barely slid. He was not wearing a seatbelt, and his body hardly moved.
He went to the emergency room that day for neck and back pain with tingling in his legs. But hospital records told a different story: he had been to the same ER just three days earlier - on August 8 - for sciatica and lower back pain. He had been dealing with chronic back trouble since around 2006.
Over the next two years, the driver had physical therapy, injections, and eventually a permanent spinal cord stimulator implanted in May 2022. After the device went in, he reported that “80 percent of his pain was gone.” A separate evaluation found he could handle all the physical demands of his job.
Warren Paving and Zurich American had paid all his medical bills and temporary total disability from September 2020 through February 2023. But they disputed the connection, arguing his problems were “due solely to a preexisting condition, disease, or lesion.”
Two neurosurgeons gave opposite takes. The driver’s treating doctor linked the treatment to the accident - then admitted under cross-examination he had no idea about the ER visit three days before the wreck and had never reviewed the driver’s earlier medical history or accident evidence.
The carrier’s neurosurgeon had reviewed all of it. He said post-accident imaging showed nothing traumatic - just wear and tear “consistent with many people in their 50s.” The spinal cord stimulator, in his view, treated long-standing spinal problems, not a collision injury.
An administrative judge initially sided with the driver. The full Mississippi Workers’ Compensation Commission reversed that call 2-1, finding the driver “was neither injured nor did he suffer an aggravation of a pre-existing condition.” It found the carrier’s expert “more persuasive because he had access to and reviewed more relevant evidence.”
The Mississippi Court of Appeals affirmed 6-3 on November 17, 2026. Three dissenting judges argued the Commission jumped the gun, ruling on the connection between the accident and the injury before the driver had a full hearing on that point.
For comp claims professionals, the case is a sharp reminder of what dashcam footage and a thorough records review can do when a claimant’s history does not line up with the story.
The decision may be subject to further review. No ruling in this article should be treated as final legal advice.