Farmers targets four El Paso clinics in $2M RICO fraud suit

Four clinics, one hallway, and a medical license for $1,000 a month
Farmers targets four El Paso clinics in $2M RICO fraud suit
RISK, COMPLIANCE & LEGAL
By Tez Romero
Nov 20, 2026

What happened: Eight Farmers Insurance entities allege four Texas clinics ran a coordinated scheme to bill over $2 million in fraudulent treatments on auto accident victims.

Who's involved: Farmers Insurance (plaintiff) versus four clinic entities and their alleged controllers.

What's at stake: More than $2 million already billed, treble damages under RICO, and a request to void all pending claims from the network.

Why it matters: The filing lays out a detailed playbook for how alleged medical billing mills use Letters of Protection, shared addresses, and rented licenses to target auto insurers.

Where it stands: Filed November 19, 2026, in the Western District of Texas.

A doctor allegedly rented his medical license for $1,000 a month. The clinics shared waiting rooms and hallways but billed Farmers as four separate providers. One patient allegedly racked up over $50,000 in charges across three of them.

That is the picture at the center of a 152-page federal RICO complaint filed by eight Farmers Insurance entities on November 19, 2026, in the Western District of Texas. The suit targets four Texas clinics - based in El Paso with one also operating in San Antonio - and five individuals, alleging they ran what the filing calls a "comprehensive scheme to defraud" the insurer through fraudulent billing on motor vehicle accident claims.

The complaint alleges that two individuals - one unlicensed in any medical field, the other a dual-licensed chiropractor and nurse practitioner - held "absolute ownership and operational control" over the four clinic entities. Together, the filing says, they built a network that funneled auto accident victims through overlapping treatment tracks at clinics that often operated out of the same physical building.

The $1,000 license

At the core of the alleged scheme was what the complaint describes as a "rent-a-doc" arrangement. One physician allegedly accepted "recurring monthly payments of approximately $1,000.00" to lend his name and credentials to the operation, the filing states. His "purported supervision was a sham executed solely to facilitate unlawful billing for medical services controlled and rendered by non-physicians," according to the complaint.

A second physician is alleged to have "voluntarily surrendered his clinical independence" under a similar arrangement. That doctor had previously been the subject of a 2024 consent order from the Texas Department of Insurance's Division of Workers' Compensation for failing to produce documentation required during a quality review, the complaint notes.

The complaint alleges the clinics were structurally illegal under Texas's Corporate Practice of Medicine doctrine - a rule that bars unlicensed individuals from owning or controlling medical practices. Because an unlicensed layperson held ownership in three of the four entities, the filing argues, every bill those clinics submitted was legally invalid from the start.

Same building, four bills

The complaint paints a picture of clinics that billed as independent providers but operated as a single enterprise. Three of the four used the same billing address in El Paso, the filing states. Patients were allegedly "escorted from room to room - or desk to desk - within the very same building," receiving referrals that "required nothing more than walking down a shared hallway."

One patient, identified only by initials, allegedly accumulated $31,960 in billings at one clinic and $18,100 at another - over $50,000 total - after a single motor vehicle accident in May 2024. Another patient allegedly ran up $38,835 across three clinics after a November 2023 accident. On the first day that patient showed up for chiropractic care, the filing alleges, the chiropractor immediately referred the patient to a second clinic before any conservative treatment had been tried.

The complaint also describes how one provider billed more than $60,000 for a single visit by combining cervical and lumbar nerve root blocks with experimental "stem cell" injections in one session.

Concussion tests without a starting point

The filing targets the clinics' alleged use of a smartphone-based concussion testing app. According to the complaint, the platform requires a healthy baseline score before any post-accident test can mean anything. But the clinics allegedly ran post-accident tests on patients for whom no baseline existed - making the results, in the complaint's words, "clinically useless."

A single neurologist allegedly processed these tests across the patient base, issuing identical conclusions every time: "always claiming the patient sustained a concussion, always directing they begin vestibular therapy, and always ordering a repeat test," the filing states. The clinics then billed four separate procedure codes per testing session, including two that federal billing rules treat as mutually exclusive on the same day.

A second swing at RICO

The timing matters. In February 2026, the Fifth Circuit dismissed a separate Farmers RICO case against different Texas medical providers - not on the substance of the fraud allegations, but because Farmers took too long to fix problems with its complaint. This new filing appears built to avoid that outcome. It cites the Fifth Circuit's January 2026 decision in Allstate Indemnity Co. v. Bhagat, which revived a $4.7 million RICO fraud suit against a Houston emergency medical center and clarified that insurers do not need to prove common-law reliance in mail-fraud-based RICO claims.

Farmers brings 11 counts including RICO claims against each of the four clinic enterprises, common law fraud, civil conspiracy, and a request for the court to declare that all pending claims from the network are void. The insurer seeks treble damages.

Whether Farmers' exhibit-heavy, 152-page approach survives the pleading challenges that ended its earlier case could shape how aggressively auto insurers pursue alleged billing mills through the federal courts.

The allegations have not been tested. No court has ruled on the merits.

Related Stories
Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB US.