Oregon ruling turns $36,500 auto settlement into $162K fee fight

A $36,500 settlement, a $162K fee request, and a trial court that got the law wrong
Oregon ruling turns $36,500 auto settlement into $162K fee fight
RISK, COMPLIANCE & LEGAL
By Regielyn Santiago
Nov 20, 2026

What happened: Oregon’s Court of Appeals reversed a fee award, ruling the trial court wrongly excluded good-faith claims from fee entitlement on a $36,500 auto settlement. 

Who’s involved: Standard Fire Insurance Company and a car-crash claimant. 

What’s at stake: A $162,694.50 attorney-fee request slashed to $40,000, now sent back for recalculation. 

Why it matters: Good-faith claims in Oregon now carry the same fee exposure as breach-of-contract claims on insurance disputes. 

Where it stands: Reversed and remanded; the trial court must recalculate fees under the corrected legal framework. 

An Oregon appeals court has handed Standard Fire Insurance Company a fresh headache - over attorney fees worth more than four times the settlement itself. 

The Oregon Court of Appeals reversed a fee award in the dispute, ruling the trial court got the law wrong when it cut a $162,694.50 fee request down to $40,000. 

The story starts with a car accident. The claimant was a passenger in a vehicle insured by Standard Fire. When the insurer refused to cover all her medical expenses, she sued on three grounds: breach of contract, breach of the duty to deal fairly under the policy - what lawyers call the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing - and a separate claim for emotional distress caused by the insurer’s handling of her case. 

The parties settled all three claims for $36,500, but they could not agree on attorney fees, so the trial court had to decide. 

Her legal team asked for $162,694.50. The court awarded $40,000. 

The four-times gap 

The difference came down to one question. Oregon law requires insurers to pay the other side’s attorney fees when a policyholder wins more than the insurer offered to settle for. The trial court decided only the straight breach-of-contract claim counted toward that fee entitlement, leaving out the good-faith claim entirely. That meant it calculated fees on a narrow slice of the legal work. 

The appeals court said that was wrong. Presiding Judge Aoyagi held that a claim for breach of the duty to deal fairly under an insurance policy counts as a claim “upon” the policy under ORS 742.061(1) - and carries the same fee entitlement as breach of contract. The court pointed to a line of Oregon decisions treating that duty as part of the insurance contract itself, where the high court treated both claims together as fee-eligible contract claims. 

Standard Fire pointed to language in Rice v. State Farm as evidence that good-faith claims do not carry fee entitlement. The appeals court was not persuaded, finding the passage was a side comment that did not address the question directly. 

What comes next 

The case goes back to the trial court for a new fee calculation that must now account for work on both the contract claim and the good-faith claim. The parties still disagree on how to divide fees between those contract-based claims and the separate emotional-distress claim. 

For claims professionals handling Oregon auto and property disputes, the ruling means good-faith claims now carry the same fee exposure as breach-of-contract claims - making every disputed denial a potentially more expensive fight. 

This is an appellate ruling on attorney fees, not a decision on the underlying insurance claims, which the parties resolved by settlement. The fee dispute has been sent back to the trial court for reconsideration. 

Related Stories
Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB US.