What happened: A California appeals court ruled a hospital cannot use a statutory lien to collect from a Medi-Cal patient’s injury settlement.
Who’s involved: Long Beach Memorial Medical Center, its attorneys Yoshida & Garcia, and auto insurer Alliance United.
What’s at stake: $7,683 in unsubmitted hospital charges, a $7,500 settlement, and a putative class action spanning four years of similar lien notices.
Why it matters: Claims teams settling third-party auto cases now have published appellate authority that hospital liens against Medi-Cal patients’ settlements are invalid.
Where it stands: Reversed and remanded - the unfair competition claim proceeds.
A hospital tried to collect $7,683 from a car accident settlement worth just $7,500 - and a California appeals court blocked it.
The Second Appellate District ruled on November 16 that Long Beach Memorial Medical Center had no right to place a hospital lien on a Medi-Cal patient’s injury settlement with the at-fault driver’s insurer, Alliance United. The court reversed the lower court’s dismissal and sent the unfair competition claim back to proceed.
The patient was hurt in a June 2020 car accident and arrived at the hospital two days later. She handed over her Medi-Cal card at the front desk. Staff confirmed she was eligible.
The hospital billed Medi-Cal for some of her treatment but never submitted $7,683 in other charges. Its attorneys, Yoshida & Garcia, mailed a lien notice to Alliance United, the at-fault driver’s insurer, threatening to enforce it.
The patient settled her injury claim for $7,500 in March 2021. Alliance United held the money because of the lien.
The lien was for more than the settlement itself.
Under California’s Hospital Lien Act, a hospital can place a lien on a patient’s injury settlement - but only if the patient actually owes the hospital money. That was the rule the California Supreme Court set down in its 2005 Parnell decision.
The appeals court applied the same logic here. When a hospital accepts Medi-Cal, it agrees to bill through the program and accept Medi-Cal rates as full payment. The patient does not owe the hospital anything extra. No debt, no lien.
The court also found that under the Medi-Cal Act, only the state agency - not the hospital - has the right to chase reimbursement from whoever caused the patient’s injuries.
The hospital argued the Hospital Lien Act shielded it from unfair competition liability. The court was not persuaded, noting the relevant case law had been settled for more than twenty years.
The case has class action dimensions. The patient filed on behalf of all Medi-Cal-eligible Californians who received hospital lien notices within four years of the original complaint.
For claims teams settling third-party auto cases in California, the ruling is now published appellate authority that hospital liens against Medi-Cal patients’ settlements have no legal basis.
The court’s decision addresses the validity of the lien and whether the unfair competition claim can go forward. The underlying class action allegations have not been tried, and no court has ruled on the merits.