What happened: Liberty Mutual alleges two carriers refused to defend additional insureds under a subcontractor's CGL and excess policies after a construction worker was injured at a Manhattan building.
Who's involved: Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company (plaintiff), State National Insurance Company and GuideOne National Insurance Company (defendants), JRM Construction Management, 560 Associates Delaware, and United States of Aritzia (additional insureds).
What's at stake: Defense costs and indemnity obligations for a personal injury lawsuit, backed by a $1 million/$2 million CGL policy and a $5 million excess policy.
Why it matters: The case tests when a carrier can disclaim additional insured coverage after a subcontractor's insurer fails to respond - or responds with a letter carrying a date that makes no sense.
Where it stands: Complaint filed November 18, 2026, in the US District Court for the Southern District of New York.
A disclaimer letter dated nearly a year before the demand it was answering. That is what Liberty Mutual says it received from one of the two carriers it asked to cover a construction-site injury at 560 Broadway in Manhattan.
The insurer filed suit in the Southern District of New York on November 18, 2026, naming State National Insurance Company and GuideOne National Insurance Company as defendants. Liberty Mutual alleges both carriers owe primary defense and coverage obligations to three companies - JRM Construction Management, 560 Associates Delaware, and Aritzia - as additional insureds under a subcontractor's policies, and that both have refused to pay up.
The underlying injury claim is straightforward. A worker employed by A Plus Plumbing Corp. alleges he was struck by a falling object at the SoHo building on June 18, 2024, while on the job for a construction project. He sued the building owner, the construction manager, and the retail tenant, claiming negligence and violations of New York Labor Law. Aritzia, the Canadian fashion retailer that now operates a flagship store at the address, was added as a defendant in December 2024.
A Plus had a purchase order and a master subcontract with JRM, the construction manager. Both contracts required the plumbing firm to carry CGL coverage of at least $2 million per occurrence and $4 million aggregate, plus a $5 million umbrella. All of it had to name JRM, the building owner, and the tenant as additional insureds on a primary, non-contributory basis - meaning A Plus's insurance was supposed to respond first and in full before anyone else's kicked in.
The policy that State National actually issued to A Plus carried lower limits: $1 million per occurrence and $2 million aggregate - half what the contract demanded. GuideOne's excess policy, sitting on top, matched the $5 million umbrella requirement.
Liberty Mutual, meanwhile, insures JRM under a separate CGL policy with a $500,000 deductible. That policy contains a clause saying it only kicks in after other available insurance has been used up. In Liberty Mutual's telling, its policy was always meant to sit above the subcontractor's coverage - not replace it.
Liberty Mutual says it asked State National and GuideOne to pick up the defense on March 27, 2025. What came back, the complaint alleges, was a disclaimer from National Claims Service on behalf of State National - but the letter carried a date of May 6, 2024.
That is nearly eleven months before the demand was even sent. The complaint calls the date "purported" and says Liberty Mutual did not receive the letter until May 12, 2025.
The reasoning in the disclaimer, as quoted in the complaint, was blunt: State National said no executed contract between A Plus and JRM had been provided, so there was no basis for additional insured coverage. It added that certificates of insurance do not create coverage. And it said there were "no allegations to review," making it "premature to respond."
Liberty Mutual alleges it sent the actual subcontract to State National in August 2025. In September 2026, its lawyers at Jaffe & Asher wrote again, enclosing the subcontract, the purchase order, and the amended complaint from the underlying lawsuit. No further coverage position came back, the complaint says.
GuideOne, the excess carrier, never responded at all.
Liberty Mutual is leaning on a New York law that requires insurers to disclaim coverage for bodily injury claims as quickly as reasonably possible. Under that rule, a late or deficient disclaimer can forfeit the insurer's right to deny coverage entirely - no questions about whether the delay actually caused harm.
The complaint alleges both State National and GuideOne lost their right to rely on any policy exclusion or condition by failing to disclaim properly and on time.
Liberty Mutual is not simply asking the court to confirm the other two carriers owe coverage. It also wants a money judgment for the defense costs it says it has absorbed by stepping in to provide a defense that should have come from elsewhere. It is currently defending all three additional insureds in the underlying lawsuit.
State National is a subsidiary of Markel Group, the Fortune 500 specialty insurer. GuideOne National is part of the GuideOne Mutual Holding Company group, an Iowa-based mutual insurer.
The gap between the contractually required CGL limits and what was actually placed - $1 million per occurrence on a job that demanded $2 million - is likely to sharpen the focus on subcontractor insurance compliance as this case moves forward.
The allegations in the complaint have not been tested, and no court has made any ruling on the merits.