What happened: A Texas appeals court reversed a jury’s zero-fee award for an attorney who won her own breach of contract case.
Who’s involved: Open Pines Condominium Owners Association and its former attorney, with Travelers Insurance in the background.
What’s at stake: $11,761.57 in unpaid fees, $67,000 in claimed attorney’s fees, and a $43,000 malpractice counterclaim - now wiped out.
Why it matters: The malpractice claim collapsed because nobody proved the insurer would have actually covered the underlying claims, even without the late-notice problem.
Where it stands: Malpractice counterclaim dismissed; attorney’s fees sent back for a new trial.
A jury decided an attorney won her breach of contract case, awarded her damages - then handed her zero dollars in fees.
The Texas Court of Appeals for the First District has now overturned that zero-fee finding and wiped out a $43,000 malpractice counterclaim along the way.
The dispute started in 2013 when Open Pines Condominium Owners Association hired an attorney to chase unpaid HOA fees from property owners. Part of that work meant suing one owner for nonpayment. That owner countersued, filing claims against Open Pines and naming the association’s president individually.
According to the president, she did not realize for several months that she had been named. By the time the association notified Travelers Insurance in March 2015, the insurer said the notice came too late and denied coverage under Open Pines’s community association management liability policy.
Open Pines fired its attorney, hired new counsel who resolved the underlying dispute successfully, and refused to pay roughly $11,000 in outstanding fees. The attorney sued for breach of contract. Open Pines countersued for malpractice, arguing the delayed notification cost it coverage and forced it to spend $43,000 on new counsel.
The jury sided with the attorney on breach of contract and awarded $11,761.57. But on attorney’s fees, it entered zero across every category - despite testimony of a $175 hourly rate, $67,000 in fees through trial, and detailed invoices.
The appeals court held that finding could not stand. Under Texas law, once a party wins a breach of contract claim and provides some evidence of fees, the jury cannot deny them outright. A zero award is permitted only when no services were provided or had no value. Open Pines offered no such evidence. The court sent fees back for a new trial.
The malpractice counterclaim met a sharper end.
To prove damages, Open Pines needed to show Travelers would have covered the underlying claims if notified on time. It could not. The only policy in evidence contained 17 exclusions for all losses and three more for losses beyond defense expenses. Travelers’ adjuster had flagged additional denial grounds - including breach of contract and unjust enrichment exclusions - beyond the late-notice issue. The denial letter explicitly reserved the right to deny on further grounds.
Open Pines’s expert - the replacement attorney - admitted she had never worked for an insurer, never trained as an adjuster, and did not know what Travelers would have done with a timely claim. The court called her testimony “no more than surmise or suspicion” and held it amounted to no evidence.
Without proof coverage would have existed, the causal chain broke. The court dismissed the counterclaim outright.
For claims teams handling late-notice denials, the decision is a concrete reminder: reserving rights on additional coverage grounds can matter years later when someone builds a malpractice claim on the assumption the insurer would have paid.