Getting agencies support through every stage of growth

Insurance agencies often need support when scaling their business. In this edition of Insurance Business TV, Smart Choice’s Ashley Wingate and Carol Drake explain how that can be done with the support of a five-star network.

To view full transcript, please click here

[00:00] We don't charge any fees to join our network. We don't charge any monthly fees.

[00:06] Paul Lucas: Hello everyone, welcome to Insurance Business TV as we meet one of this year's winners at the Five Star Networks and Alliances. Every year Insurance Business America asks its retail broker audience what they think of the services and advantages supplied by networks across the US. And today we're meeting Ashley Wingate. He is Executive Vice President, Sales and Distribution at Smart Choice, who can talk us through his firm's success. Ashley, welcome to Insurance Business TV.

[00:32] Ashley Wingate: Thank you Paul, very glad to be here and appreciate you having me.

[00:35] Paul Lucas: So obviously Smart Choice is doing something right with Ashley's award. Tell us what it does to kind of go beyond what is expected of a network. So I guess what level of expertise does it provide that is perhaps a little bit different to other networks and indeed how are those Smart Choice territory managers differentiated from those elsewhere?

[00:56] Ashley Wingate: So I think what sets our territory managers aside is they're out there in the field every day working with our agency partners, working on their needs, going deeper, getting to know what they need, trying to add the carriers or maybe the support they need. It could be helping them with errors and omissions. It could be helping them with a comparative rater like EasyLinks. It could be helping them with a management system. So it might not just be market access that day.

[01:26] They ultimately become a trusted advisor in our roughly just under 12,000 agency members across the country. And so I really think that team effort of everyone at the home office at Smart Choice and in the field working with our agency partners that cares every day about supporting our agents and the network and helping them succeed is really where the winning combination comes together.

[01:53] Paul Lucas: And today we're meeting Carol Drake, Senior Vice President of Personal Lines at Smart Choice, who can talk us through her firm's success. Carol, welcome to Insurance Business TV.

[02:03] Carol Drake: Oh, well, thank you so much for having me.

[02:05] Paul Lucas: Do the Smart Choice field teams just get agencies started or do they participate throughout the life cycle of an agency? So, start-up, growth, acquisitions, transition.

[02:15] Carol Drake: We're there from day one. So, we help start-up agencies from everything to getting them their first E&O coverage, how to start with raters, how to actually start working with carriers, even before they get their first direct sub count. So, we have solutions from beginning to our Smart Start programs for personal and commercial line to helping them achieve different contracts with carriers directly, as well as to grow that agency, be successful, and eventually, if they ever choose, how to make sure that they're thinking ahead, perpetuation as they're continuing to grow.

[02:58] Who's that next leader in their company? How are they growing? How are they attracting new agents and CSRs? We're there every step of the way. We have a program for all of those things. And our state directors and in-territory managers, they're there. So, we have state meetings in their local area. We have lunch and learns. So, we bring in carrier partners and invite agents and sit down and have a real conversation.

[03:29] I think those are probably my most favorite, where you can really sit with your peers in a small group setting and have that conversation. And of course, there's one-on-one interaction, right? So, they're calling, texting, emailing, anything that we can do to help them each and every step of their business's journey from start-up all the way through growth, acquisitions, and, if they are ready to hit that next chapter, we also have an ability to help them in the transition to sell their agency.

[03:59] We're there with them and I think that that's one of the strengths of a network. It's having that wealth of knowledge or someone to go to to help you find what you're looking for because that's the hardest part, right? You don't know what you don't know, but our PMs and state directors, because they have been owners and they worked with carriers for so many years, they've run across almost any scenario that our agent is going to have throughout their life cycle.

[04:26] Paul Lucas: So, let's just as well about how you help agencies diversify their revenue and indeed why is that so important?

[04:34] Ashley Wingate: I think a lot of agencies across the country through the personal lines hard market that we all just went through, one of the hardest and longest personal lines markets we've had in a long time, learned a valuable lesson of diversifying the portfolio inside the agency.

[04:51] Smart Choice had really made a move about 10 years prior pushing commercial lines and what we call our express markets vertical and that's really our large wholesale brokers and specialty niche markets like coastal homeowners. We have a partner Hagerty Insurance who does classic cars, not just your everyday auto and home.

[05:15] I think for us as a network, because we had diversified our options and what we could offer our independent agency partners in the commercial space as well as in some of the E&S space and specialty niche markets, we were able to come alongside them when the personal lines market slowed up. There was a lot of slowing and pausing in new business as they worked to regain their traction in the market to move forward.

[05:44] And so for our agency partners, having that access to write that business helped them survive that market, that incredibly challenging market where unfortunately we did see some smaller agencies go out of business. You did see some smaller carriers go out of business that were focused only on personal lines as well.

[06:02] So I think diversification in the portfolio as a network like we do is incredibly important, but I also believe diversification for our agency partners is key for their long-term success.

[06:16] Paul Lucas: And speaking of diversity, Carol, as well, of course there are many differences in the contracts that insurance networks offer. So tell us about some of the concerns that an agent might have with a presented contract and indeed how is the Smart Choice contract different?

[06:31] Carol Drake: What's terrific is this contract was designed by our founder, Doug Witcher, back in 1994. He was an independent agent and these are the things that he found to be most important and that's why this contract is so agent-friendly and that's why we've had so much success in recruiting new agents.

[06:49] In addition to the 1,500 new agents last year, we have recruited over 1,000 new agents for the last nine years and there is no slowing down. So we're on pace to exceed that in 2026. So when it comes to a friendly agent contract, I think you have to really review that very strongly and definitely make sure that you're looking at a Smart Choice contract.

[07:12] Paul Lucas: Well, clearly Smart Choice must be doing something right as this award reflects, Carol, but looking to the future, what new programs do you have? And I know there's maybe one coming up with a major highly popular carrier that you think is going to benefit agents that have partnered with Smart Choice.

[07:28] Carol Drake: Absolutely. We have over 100 different carriers throughout the country and our most recent partnership, I'm very excited to say, is GEICO.

[07:39] We have already come out with over 3,000 agency partnerships with GEICO and that's just the tip of the iceberg. We're going to continue to grow throughout the entire country and I think they're going to be a terrific partner and that's what agents are looking for. They're looking for market access and with GEICO we're bringing them that.

[08:00] Paul Lucas: Yeah, clearly a lot to be excited about with Smart Choice. I'm sure a lot of brokers will be reaching out to find out more. A huge thanks for your time today. Thanks, of course, to you for watching. We'll see you next time right here on Insurance Business TV.

[08:14] [music]

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB US.