UnitedHealth owed $192 million in 2024 group MLR rebates

State-by-state data from the CMS public use file gives advisors a documented reference point for the 2026 and 2027 renewal conversation
UnitedHealth owed $192 million in 2024 group MLR rebates
GROUP BENEFITS
By Mark Rosanes
Nov 16, 2026

Health insurers reported $460 million in federal medical loss ratio (MLR) rebates across the small and large group markets for the 2024 reporting year, according to a Planlined analysis of the CMS 2024 MLR public use file published November 14. Planlined is a benefits proposal software company for employee benefits brokers. Its figures are drawn directly from insurer submissions to Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) and are independently verifiable against the agency’s own published data.

The group market total breaks down to $274 million in small group and $185.9 million in large group, using CMS’s published state summary figures. According to Planlined’s aggregation of issuer-level filings, UnitedHealth Group, filing as UNITEDHEALTH GRP, owed the largest rebates in both markets: $94.2 million in small group across 29 state filings, and $98 million in large group across 27 state filings. Elevance Health was the second-largest small group payer at $77.3 million, while Independence Blue Cross Group ranked second in large group at $20.6 million.

Individual issuer figures in the Planlined analysis are verifiable against the CMS public use file. Parent-company aggregations reflect Planlined’s grouping of related legal entities.

The state picture is uneven. Massachusetts led small group at $54.4 million, driven largely by Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts and Mass General Brigham Health Plan. Pennsylvania led large group at $27.1 million, with Independence Assurance Company and Highmark Group the principal contributors. Thirteen states and territories had no rebates in either group market, among them Alaska, North Dakota, and West Virginia.

How to use this data at the renewal table

The ERISA compliance obligations that attach to MLR rebate receipt cover the distribution side: how to calculate the plan-asset portion, what allocation methods satisfy the Department of Labor’s Technical Release 2011-4, and the December 30 deadline for employers that received their rebate on September 30. The state-level carrier data serves a different purpose.

A rebate means the carrier’s pooled three-year ratio in that state and market fell short of the MLR standard. For small and large group plans the standard is 80% and 85% respectively, measured over 2022 through 2024. It says nothing about any individual employer’s claims experience, since rebate calculations reflect the carrier’s entire book of business in that state and market, rather than a single group’s performance. 

What it does provide is documented context. A carrier proposing a significant rate increase for the 2026 or 2027 plan year while having owed a rebate in that state and market is a data point that belongs in the renewal conversation.

The rate pressure already visible in the small group market makes that examination more pointed. When insurers request median increases of 14% for small group in 2027 while returning premium because their three-year loss ratio fell short, the renewal conversation benefits from that additional layer of information.

The Planlined data also identifies the self-funded boundary. MLR rules apply only to fully insured arrangements. Self-funded plans, including most level-funded structures, file no MLR reports and owe no rebates regardless of their loss ratios. The distinction sharpens as group health insurer margin compression pushes more mid-market employers to evaluate funding alternatives at renewal.

Finding the data

Planlined provides two free downloads from the analysis: a state and market CSV covering all 56 jurisdictions in the CMS file, and an issuer CSV listing every filing that owed a rebate with its NAIC company code. The issuer file is the more practical starting point, since rebates attach to the legal entity that issued the policy in a given state and market, rather than to the parent brand. A client covered under a UnitedHealthcare plan in Florida may be with a different issuing entity than one covered in Wisconsin, and the rebate obligation follows the issuer.

The CMS 2024 MLR public use file, from which all figures are drawn, is available directly from the CMS’s Center for Consumer Information and Insurance Oversight (CCIIO).

Planlined discloses a $5.5 million difference between its public use file totals and CMS’s own published state summary PDF, concentrated in a small number of state and market cells. The discrepancy is documented and the company reports the insurer filing figures as submitted, without adjusting toward CMS’s summary. CMS has not published an explanation for the difference.

Related Stories
Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB US.