El Niño threatens California’s widening flood coverage gap

Surplus lines are replacing admitted cover across the state, often without flood protection
El Niño threatens California’s widening flood coverage gap
CATASTROPHE & FLOOD
By Roxanne San Jose
Nov 16, 2026

California’s commercial property market is heading into an unusually active storm season while carrying one of the largest flood coverage gaps in the country.

New research from London-based specialty insurer Atrium finds that El Niño winters produce an average of 19% more intense storm events along the US west coast than non-El Niño years – 104 events compared with the non-El Niño average of 87. Those storms frequently generate flooding, flash flooding, landslides, and mudslides: perils that standard commercial and homeowners policies typically exclude.

The forecast for this season is severe. The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration’s (NOAA) Climate Prediction Center reported in October 2026 that a strong-to-very strong El Niño is likely to persist through January to March 2027, at greater than a 79% probability. The chance of a “historic” event – defined as sea surface temperatures exceeding +2.5°C on the three-month Relative Oceanic Niño Index, surpassing every El Niño on record since 1950 – sits at approximately 60% for the October-to-December period. The full NOAA forecast is available at the Climate Prediction Center’s ENSO advisory page.

Read more: El Niño arrives: what US property brokers should tell clients now

Thomas Hobbs, joint head of North American property binding authority at Atrium in London, said the conditions entering this winter are unlike anything the market has seen in recent memory.

“Many are predicting that this winter could see the strongest El Niño of our lifetimes. That will likely mean more storms, more property damage and more losses for real estate owners,” Hobbs said.

He noted that while El Niño typically suppresses storm activity along the southeastern US seaboard, it intensifies it along the west coast – a geographic reversal that concentrates exposure in California’s already pressured commercial property market.

The flood coverage gap

California’s flood protection numbers confirm the scale of the problem. According to Neptune Flood’s April 2026 analysis of Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) data, just 1.4% of residential properties in the state carry flood insurance, despite 2.3 million properties facing flood risk over the next 30 years. Neptune Flood is a private flood insurer with a commercial interest in expanding take-up, but its figures draw on federal National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) policy data. That same analysis found that participation in the NFIP has fallen 35% since 2016, even as premiums have climbed by more than 33% over the same period. Where NFIP coverage does exist, the program’s $250,000 residential building limit often represents less than a third of actual rebuild costs in California.

Karen Collins, vice president of property and environmental at the American Property Casualty Insurance Association (APCIA) in Washington DC, said in comments to ABC7 Los Angeles in November 2026 that the gap is poorly understood until it is too late. “Many don’t realize that a standard homeowner’s policy will not cover flood damage that is really from coastal surge, as we’ve seen from Tropical Storm Rachel, or any other flooding from the ground up,” Collins said.

The commercial picture is similarly exposed. The Surplus Line Association of California’s 2025 annual report documented a structural shift in the state’s insurance market, with the surplus lines share of California’s commercial property sector growing from 6% in 2014 to 20% by 2025. Many of those placements carry narrower coverage and higher deductibles than the admitted policies they replaced. Brokers working with California commercial accounts can review the California Department of Insurance’s September 2026 guidance on flood and mudslide coverage exclusions for detailed policy-level context. That alert confirmed that commercial policies typically exclude damage from flooding, mudslides, and debris flows unless caused directly or indirectly by a wildfire or another covered peril.

Burn scar risk and the secondary peril problem

Hobbs drew attention to landslide and debris flow risks that many commercial clients have not yet addressed.

“Major commercial property owners in California must ensure that their levels of coverage reflect an increased risk not only of storms themselves, but even of second-order effects like landslides. Some analysts believe that California’s wildfires over the past few summers have left some areas of the state particularly vulnerable to landslides and mudslides during periods of very heavy rain,” he said.

The California Governor’s Office of Emergency Services (Cal OES) confirms that wildfire burn scars alter soil structure and remove vegetation, leaving terrain prone to debris flows and flooding – a risk that persists for years after a fire. The Eaton and Palisades fires of January 2025 left extensive burn scars in the Los Angeles foothills that remain active hazards entering this storm season.

Read more: California announces state of emergency as record El Niño builds

Renewal conversations before the storm window closes

Hobbs tied adequate coverage directly to business continuity.

“Businesses need to ensure they are resilient now, ahead of the winter. The impacts of businesses closing because of a major storm have enormous knock-on effects through the local and regional economy, for customers, suppliers and employees. Businesses that are insured appropriately get back to work much more quickly,” he said.

The NFIP’s standard 30-day waiting period before flood coverage takes effect makes timing critical – a point Collins also raised. That means the window for action is now, not after the first storm arrives.

For brokers with California commercial accounts, three conversations need to happen before renewal: whether property limits reflect current replacement costs; whether flood coverage – through the NFIP or the private market – is in place and adequate; and whether secondary perils such as mudslides and debris flows from burn scar zones are addressed. Standard and surplus lines placements routinely exclude the last two. Background on the NFIP’s declining California participation and the state’s growing private flood market is available in earlier coverage.

NOAA expects El Niño to continue strengthening before beginning to weaken in early 2027, with its peak intensity concentrated in the November-to-January window.

Related Stories
Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB US.