Sports insurance becomes a deliberate broker acquisition target

Record sports participation is driving specialty broker M&A into the sports and fitness sector
Sports insurance becomes a deliberate broker acquisition target
MERGERS & ACQUISITIONS
By Roxanne San Jose
Nov 18, 2026

Highstreet Insurance Partners has acquired the retail brokerage business of Player’s Health, moving directly into sports insurance as well-capitalized platforms compete to own a niche that generalist brokers have long underserved.

Traverse City, Michigan-based Highstreet announced the deal on November 17, 2026. Player’s Health, a Minneapolis, Minnesota-based agency specializing in risk management and coverage for sports organizations, teams, leagues, fitness centers, and event organizers, will operate as Highstreet’s new Sports & Fitness practice from December 1, 2026. Player’s Health founder and CEO Tyrre Burks will continue to lead the business.

Financial terms were not disclosed.

Read more: Howden launches dedicated US sports & entertainment division

Multiple brokers targeting sports insurance in 2026

Highstreet is not moving alone. In September 2026, global broker Howden formally launched a dedicated US sports and entertainment practice, naming Robbie Henderson to lead it from New York. Two well-resourced platforms entering the same vertical inside two months signals a shift: sports insurance is no longer incidental business for brokers – it is a vertical platforms are actively building toward.

Team sports participation in the US reached a record 92.3 million Americans aged six and older in 2025, a 7.6% increase marking the fifth consecutive year of growth, according to the Sports & Fitness Industry Association’s (SFIA) 2026 US Trends in Team Sports Report – Participation Foundational Data, published September 24, 2026, at sfia.org. More participants mean more programs, more facilities, and a broader liability exposure base across youth leagues, fitness centers, event organizers, and collegiate sports.

For brokers already placing sports or fitness accounts with generalist carriers, that growth creates both opportunity and risk. Organizations that have outgrown standard general liability or accident medical products may be underinsured – and may not know it.

Credibility as the acquisition rationale

Highstreet’s stated reason for the deal centers on expertise and market standing rather than geography. Todd Macumber, chief growth officer of Highstreet, said the acquisition brings the relationships and community knowledge required to build a differentiated practice.

“Launching a new industry practice requires more than specialized insurance expertise. It requires credibility, relationships and a deep understanding of the community you serve. Tyrre brings all three,” Macumber said.

Burks played college football at Winona State University and in the Canadian Football League before founding Player’s Health in 2015. By 2024, the company protected more than 5.5 million athletes across 40,000 programs nationwide. In December 2024, Burks told Sportico the firm had written $80 million in premiums across 15,000 policies that year – a figure from before the Highstreet transition.

“Highstreet gives us the resources and capabilities to broaden the solutions we can bring to clients while staying true to our commitment to safety, accessible care and the communities we serve,” Burks said.

Specialty broker M&A pace accelerates across the market

This acquisition follows Highstreet raising $550 million through a delayed draw term loan led by Ares Capital, announced August 6, 2025, to fund ongoing acquisitions. The capital was upsized from an initial $500 million target due to investor demand, according to Highstreet’s announcement at hsip.com. Founded in 2018, Highstreet has completed more than 170 acquisitions across the US, primarily adding geographic footprint. This deal takes a different approach – it acquires a client segment defined by risk profile rather than location.

That pattern sits within a broader market movement. According to MarshBerry’s “Specialty Market Review – Year in Review 2025,” there were 149 announced specialty firm M&A transactions in 2025, a 24% increase year over year. MarshBerry noted that large broker platforms are increasingly acquiring specialty businesses to capture more of the distribution chain and differentiate on underwriting knowledge – a rationale that applies directly to sports and fitness insurance.

Read more: The $2 billion sports insurance market – and the risks reshaping it

For brokers tracking how well-capitalized platforms are using acquisitions to claim niche verticals, the trend has direct implications for which risks remain independently placed and which get absorbed into specialist practices with greater underwriting depth and capital behind them.

Related Stories
Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB US.