Copy-pasted notary page sinks condo association’s $4.3M storm claim

The notary page was identical. The dollar amounts were not
Copy-pasted notary page sinks condo association’s $4.3M storm claim
RISK, COMPLIANCE & LEGAL
By Regielyn Santiago
Nov 20, 2026

What happened: The Seventh Circuit ruled a condo association’s proof of loss was not “sworn” because its notary page came from a different document. 

Who’s involved: Tower Crossing Condominium Association and insurer Affiliated FM Insurance Company. 

What’s at stake: A $4,341,149.36 storm damage claim, now time-barred. 

Why it matters: Proof-of-loss form requirements are strictly enforced - getting close is not enough to pause the lawsuit clock. 

Where it stands: Decided. The Seventh Circuit affirmed summary judgment for Affiliated FM on November 19, 2026. 

One notary page. Two proofs of loss. Two very different dollar amounts. And a $4.3 million storm damage claim that never made it to trial. 

The Seventh Circuit has ruled against Tower Crossing Condominium Association without a trial, finding its proof of loss was not “sworn” as the policy required - because the notary page attached to it came from a different proof of loss entirely. 

Tower Crossing manages a condo complex in Glenview, Illinois, insured by Affiliated FM Insurance Company under an all-risk policy. A storm damaged the roof on July 2, 2019, and the two sides spent over two years investigating and negotiating. 

The policy required a “signed and sworn” proof of loss and gave Tower Crossing two years to file suit - with the clock paused only while a proof of loss was under review. 

Same stamp, different number 

With the extended deadline about to expire on October 2, 2021, the board president signed and had notarized a proof of loss on September 30 valuing the roof replacement at $2,954,405.44. He did not submit it. The next day, Tower Crossing submitted a different proof of loss - this one valued at $4,341,149.36 - with the exact same notary certificate, same date, identically placed stamp. 

The same notary page, on a document nearly $1.4 million higher. 

Affiliated FM spotted the duplicate during discovery. The board president admitted he had “attached” his “sworn signature” from the first proof of loss to the second. Tower Crossing sued on November 19, 2021 - but the deadline had already passed. 

What does “sworn” actually mean? 

Tower Crossing argued a simple promise was enough and pointed to dictionary definitions it had selectively trimmed. The court was not persuaded, noting the association had “craftily” edited the quotes to strip out any reference to an oath. Every dictionary the court checked - Black’s Law, Merriam-Webster, Cambridge, Dictionary.com - said the same thing: “sworn” means an oath was taken. 

The court also pointed out that “sworn” has to mean something different from “signed” - otherwise the policy used two words where one would do. That extra meaning was an oath. 

“Close enough” was not the standard 

Tower Crossing’s fallback was that its submission was close enough to count. The court shut that down: Illinois law requires a proof of loss “in whatever form is required by the policy” before the lawsuit clock pauses. If the form is not met, the clock keeps running. 

Because the submitted proof of loss was never sworn to, the two-year window was never paused. It expired on October 2, 2021. The suit filed seven weeks later was too late. 

A notary page attests to one specific document on one specific date - not to whatever it gets stapled to later. 

This case was decided by the US Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit on November 19, 2026, affirming the district court’s ruling for Affiliated FM. No petition for rehearing or further appeal is reflected in the decision reviewed. 

Related Stories
Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB US.