Missouri targets not-at-fault surcharges in auto rate overhaul

A ban on not-at-fault premium hikes heads the two-rule package
Missouri targets not-at-fault surcharges in auto rate overhaul
RISK, COMPLIANCE & LEGAL
By Tez Romero
Nov 20, 2026
  • What changed: Missouri published two proposed rules establishing rate standards for private-passenger auto insurance. The centerpiece – new 20 CSR 500-2.650 – bans insurers from raising premiums because of a not-at-fault accident and requires actuarial justification for every rate and rating variable.
  • Who’s affected: Private-passenger auto insurers, underwriters, actuarial teams, and compliance departments operating in Missouri.
  • Next step: Written comments close approximately December 16, 2026 (30 days from publication). A public hearing is set for 10:00 a.m. on December 22, 2026, in Jefferson City, Missouri. Both rules take effect for policies issued or renewed on or after January 1, 2028.

The Missouri Department of Commerce and Insurance (DCI) published two linked proposed rules in the November 16, 2026 Missouri Register, signaling a significant shift in how the state regulates private-passenger automobile insurance pricing.

The first rule – proposed 20 CSR 500-2.650 – introduces a formal definition of an unfairly discriminatory rate for the personal auto line. Under the proposal, a rate qualifies as unfairly discriminatory if it is not actuarially justified, if it is higher than it would otherwise be as a result of a claim from a not-at-fault accident, or if it fails to equitably reflect differences in expected losses and expenses.

A not-at-fault accident is defined as one where the insured bears less than 50% of the fault or is reimbursed by another party. The definition covers weather-related damage, incidents involving lawfully parked vehicles, and rear-end or hit-and-run collisions where the insured holds no moving-violation conviction.

The practical upshot for carriers: no rating plan, tiering model, or classification system may produce a higher premium for any policyholder on the basis of a not-at-fault claim. The prohibition applies regardless of the mechanism – whether the surcharge flows through classification, reclassification, tiering, or any other pathway in the rating algorithm.

Alongside the surcharge ban, the proposal requires insurers to demonstrate actuarial justification for all rates, rating algorithms, rating variables, rating plans, and rating systems filed with the DCI director. Each rating variable must show a statistical correlation with future losses or coverage costs, supported by a reasonable explanation available within the filing on request.

The rule also imposes a consumer-notice requirement: any premium notice reflecting an increase tied to an at-fault motor vehicle incident must identify the specific incident that triggered the higher charge.

A companion amendment to the existing 20 CSR 500-2.600 creates the transition framework. It limits the current rate-increase rule to policies issued or renewed before January 1, 2028, handing off to the new 20 CSR 500-2.650 from that date forward. Both rules are authorized under sections 374.045 and 379.470 of the Missouri Revised Statutes.

The DCI estimates a private-sector cost of $350,000 in the aggregate. For compliance teams, the rulemaking means auditing rating systems to confirm that no not-at-fault accident classification – however indirect – produces a premium increase, and that actuarial support for every variable is documented and filing-ready.

Related Stories
Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB US.