What happened: A Michigan appeals court upheld a jury verdict finding a driver negligent but the plaintiff uninjured, despite multiple spinal surgeries
Who’s involved: Progressive Marathon Insurance Company and Liberty Mutual Insurance Company as defendants alongside the at-fault driver
What’s at stake: The plaintiff’s damages claim for neck, back, and head injuries requiring several lumbar fusions
Why it matters: Prior-accident history combined with expert imaging testimony severed causation even where surgeries suggested serious harm
Where it stands: Affirmed by the Michigan Court of Appeals on November 17, 2026; unpublished opinion
Three prior accidents, multiple spinal fusions - and a Michigan jury that said this particular crash did not cause any injury at all.
A state appeals court has now upheld that split verdict in a case where the driver was found negligent but the plaintiff came away with nothing.
The case was heard in Oakland Circuit Court and affirmed by the Michigan Court of Appeals on November 17. The plaintiff was involved in a motor-vehicle collision and reported neck and back pain along with headaches. Her medical provider diagnosed head and spinal injuries, determined she was disabled from work and daily tasks, and she underwent several lumbar fusions.
The plaintiff’s medical past told a different story. She had three significant prior accidents: a motor-vehicle crash ten years earlier requiring treatment for brain, shoulder, and knee injuries; another five years earlier that led to shoulder, knee, and hand surgeries plus aggravation of her previous back and brain injuries; and a slip-and-fall just one week before the collision at issue, involving her knee and ankle.
Before trial, the plaintiff tried to keep all of it out, arguing the evidence “would unfairly suggest to the jury that Plaintiff is a ‘career claimant’ or someone who habitually seeks to profit from car accidents.” The court denied that motion.
At trial, defense counsel highlighted the plaintiff’s prior accidents, surgeries, and lawsuits with the same counsel, using visual displays throughout.
The defense’s expert, a brain-and-spine radiologist, compared MRI imaging of the plaintiff’s spine from five years before the accident with scans taken a month and a half after. His conclusion: “no objective change between pre-accident and post-accident imaging of the cervical spine.”
The plaintiff’s counsel called the undisclosed comparison images “classic trial by ambush.” The court offered a fix - a second deposition with full knowledge of the comparison scans. The plaintiff declined.
On appeal, the court saw no problem. The scans were of the plaintiff herself, and there was nothing in the record to explain why her own legal team did not already have them. The expert had reached the same conclusion using only the post-accident images; the earlier scans merely “confirmed” it.
The plaintiff also argued the defense used her prior-accident history to attack her credibility rather than to address causation. But she never objected to those specific uses at trial. Without a timely objection, the appeals court held, the issue was waived.
The jury found the defendant negligent but concluded the plaintiff did not suffer an injury or aggravation of a preexisting condition. It never reached proximate cause or damages.
For auto claims teams, the practical takeaway is direct: prior-accident history paired with objective imaging evidence severed causation here even where multiple surgeries pointed to serious harm - and unpreserved trial objections closed the door on appeal.
The opinion is unpublished and not binding precedent in Michigan.