A Reuters special report has revealed that Green Century Funds and Calvert Funds – two leading US money managers focused on corporate environmental, social and governance matters - are both reassessing their stakes in the international brokerage firm based on its green credentials.
The investors are questioning A.J. Gallagher’s investment into 34 ‘refined coal’ facilities, which essentially use coal-upgrading technology to make it burn cleaner and release fewer pollutants and emissions. Refined coal facilities do, however, still release smog and chemicals that can be harmful to the environment.
A.J. Gallagher also holds a 46.5% stake in Chem-Mod LLC, which provides the chemicals used to produce refined coal. According to Reuters, thanks to heavy refined coal subsidies from the US government, the brokerage giant has accrued about US$850 million (about CA$1.1 billion) worth of US government tax credits from its ‘clean coal’ investments.
The brokerage is one of about 360 companies in the US$250 million Green Century Equity Fund GECQX.O, which advertises itself as “100% fossil fuel free.” Its investments into so-called ‘clean coal’ potentially contradict the green principals of the asset manager.
Green Century released a statement describing clean coal as “a myth”. The firm also stated: “In light of this new information, we certainly will … press [A.J. Gallagher] to stop profiting from schemes devised by the fossil fuel industry to the detriment to US citizens and taxpayers.”
Likewise, Calvert Research and Management, which holds A.J. Gallagher shares in its US$1.3 billion Calvert US Large Cap Core Responsible Index Fund, has released a statement saying it has “contacted A.J. Gallagher and will consider this information in our assessment of environmental, social and governance (ESG) performance.”
According to Reuters, shares in the brokerage giant are held in at least ten other mutual funds that screen companies on ESG criteria, including one run by Vanguard Group. But as Vanguard spokesman John Woerth told Reuters: “There’s no universally-accepted definition of ESG.”
A.J. Gallagher has not yet responded to messages seeking comment about this matter.