What happened: Ontario's appeal court upheld a $10 million sub-limit on code-upgrade costs after a flood damaged Thunder Bay's wastewater plant
Who's involved: City of Thunder Bay (insured), Ontario Municipal Insurance Exchange (insurer), Royal & Sun Alliance and Catlin Canada (reinsurers)
What's at stake: Whether code upgrades fell under the $300 million general policy limit or a $10 million sub-limit
Why it matters: Reinforces that "Demolition and Increased Cost of Construction" clauses cap betterment costs, even on large municipal policies
Where it stands: Appeal dismissed November 17, 2026; costs of $25,000 awarded to the insurer
Fifty-five percent. That is how much of the total repair bill for a flooded Ontario sewage plant went toward bringing the facility up to modern building codes - and it is the share the insurer says falls under a $10 million cap, not the policy's $300 million general limit.
The Ontario Court of Appeal has sided with the insurer, ruling that a policy sub-limit for code-upgrade work applies to the full scope of those upgrades, regardless of the broader coverage the city thought it had purchased.
The dispute centres on the City of Thunder Bay's Wastewater Pollution Control Plant, originally built in 1964 and expanded over the following decades. By 2012, parts of the facility no longer met contemporary building codes and bylaws.
That year, a heavy rainstorm overwhelmed the plant's sewer systems. Raw sewage flooded tunnels and affected many of the plant's buildings. Thunder Bay made a claim under its property policy with the Ontario Municipal Insurance Exchange, known as Omex. The insurer accepted that losses were covered and appointed adjusters.
The problems started during the rebuild. As the city repaired the plant, it also upgraded the facility to comply with current codes and bylaws. Omex took the position that those upgrades - which the insurer said made up 55% of the total repair costs - were not ordinary repair expenses. Instead, Omex pointed to a clause in the policy titled "Demolition and Increased Cost of Construction," which had its own $10 million sub-limit listed in the policy's declarations.
The city disagreed. Thunder Bay argued the clause was designed to extend coverage, not restrict it - an add-on that brought code-upgrade costs within the $300 million general limit. The city also pointed out that it had paid premiums based on the full replacement cost of the property, a figure that would include the cost of building a code-compliant facility from scratch.
Both sides asked the court to settle the question. The lower court found the policy language clear: the clause set a $10 million ceiling on code-upgrade costs. It did not create a separate pool of coverage above the general limit. It identified a specific type of loss and capped it.
The Court of Appeal, in a unanimous decision, agreed. The court found that the clause "is meant to apply to any code upgrades to the property, capping coverage for compliance costs at $10 million." The opening words of the clause, the court noted, explicitly tie it to any loss that triggers "the enforcement of any law, bylaw or similar ordinance regulating the construction or repair of damaged facilities." Accepting the city's interpretation, the court said, would render the sub-limit meaningless.
As for Thunder Bay's argument that the policy was ambiguous and should be read in light of the parties' intentions, the court found no ambiguity to trigger that analysis. Because the wording was clear, there was no need to look beyond it.
The decision also addressed a point that matters well beyond this particular plant. Replacement cost coverage includes an element of what insurers call betterment - putting the insured in a better position than before the loss, because the payout covers depreciation. But the court confirmed that insurers can cap how much they pay for that improvement, particularly when the extra cost comes from bringing an older building up to current codes.
The court pointed to the Supreme Court of Canada's recent decision in Emond v. Trillium Mutual Insurance Co., 2026 SCC 3, which warned that "courts have generally avoided interpretations of this nature, which would transform the insurer into a guarantor for the insured's regulatory non-compliance."
For property claims teams and underwriters handling ageing municipal or commercial infrastructure, the decision makes it clear that a broad general limit does not override a specific cap on code-upgrade costs - even when the insured has been paying premiums on the full replacement value.
The appeal was dismissed with costs of $25,000 to the respondents. Royal & Sun Alliance Insurance Company of Canada and Catlin Canada Inc., named as co-defendants, are Omex's reinsurers.