What happened: An Ontario auto claimant’s catastrophic impairment application was frozen after she refused to attend insurer exams without her own support person.
Who’s involved: Certas Home and Auto Insurance Company and a claimant injured in a 2018 auto accident.
What’s at stake: Catastrophic impairment classification under Criterion 8, plus $7,805.19 in assessment costs and $1,288.20 for support person services.
Why it matters: The ruling confirms that physically arriving at an insurer examination is not the same as complying - claimants must complete the assessment as arranged.
Where it stands: Preliminary ruling issued November 12, 2026; hearing adjourned to May-June 2027.
An Ontario auto claimant showed up to every insurer examination on her file, but the tribunal ruled that was not enough.
The problem was not whether she arrived. It was what happened once she got there.
In a ruling released November 12, 2026, Ontario’s Licence Appeal Tribunal found that a claimant who attended insurer examinations but refused to go through with them unless her own support person stayed in the room had not met her obligations under Ontario’s accident benefits rules. Her application to be classified as catastrophically impaired is now on ice until she completes the exams without conditions.
The claimant was hurt in a December 2018 auto accident and sought accident benefits from Certas Home and Auto Insurance Company. The dispute came to a head when she applied for a catastrophic impairment determination - a classification under Ontario’s benefits schedule that governs the level of benefits available.
Certas arranged two assessments to evaluate the claim: one with an occupational therapist, one with a psychiatrist. Neither got off the ground.
At the occupational therapy in-home assessment on February 5, 2026, the claimant brought a registered nurse as her personal support worker. That session ended early when she became nauseated. When rescheduled for April 6, two additional people arrived with her. The claimant refused to proceed without them in the room.
One week later, at a psychiatric assessment on April 13, the same impasse. She would not participate unless her support person stayed.
Certas wrote to the claimant on April 23, 2026, declaring her non-compliant. The insurer cited professional college guidelines that advise against letting the claimant choose who observes. It offered an independent chaperone instead. She did not agree.
The claimant had attended 17 prior assessments between March 2018 and September 2025 without a support person. She provided no medical evidence explaining why she now needed one.
The tribunal pointed to an earlier ruling - Spiegel v. Intact Insurance Company - which established that it has no power to dictate how an insurer runs its examinations. The adjudicator was direct: “Physical presence is not enough. The applicant was under a duty to cooperate with the assessors.”
The ruling does not bar the claimant entirely. She may still pursue $7,805.19 in outstanding assessment costs and $1,288.20 for support person services. But the catastrophic impairment determination - the claim that carries the most weight - is frozen until she sits for the exams without conditions.
The hearing has been adjourned to a window between May 3 and June 28, 2027.
For Ontario claims teams managing catastrophic impairment files, the practical point is blunt: getting a claimant through the door is not the same as getting them assessed.
This is a preliminary ruling on procedural compliance. No findings have been made on the merits of the catastrophic impairment claim, and the matter remains before the tribunal.