AI lets scammers turn one data breach into thousands of targets, Aviva expert says

James South says scammers almost always try to create a sense of urgency, so treat every unexpected request with a bit of skepticism
AI lets scammers turn one data breach into thousands of targets, Aviva expert says
CYBER
By Branislav Urosevic
Nov 17, 2026

Artificial intelligence is giving cybercriminals new ways to target large numbers of people using stolen personal information, increasing the importance of basic security precautions and consumer awareness, according to James South (pictured), AVP of Specialty Personal Insurance at Aviva.

Major data breaches can expose information belonging to thousands of people, creating opportunities for malicious actors to use that data in subsequent scams. South said AI can help criminals exploit such information at scale, making it easier to target many potential victims rather than approaching individuals one at a time.

Read more: Personal cyber cover is playing catch-up as most Canadians don’t know it exists

“They can do it en masse to tens of thousands of customers at a time and have their information stolen,” South told Insurance Business.

The risk extends beyond the organization initially targeted. Personal information held by businesses, public institutions and other organizations can ultimately be used to reach consumers through fraudulent calls, emails and other communications.

South said consumers should pay particular attention to how scammers attempt to manipulate their behaviour, including by creating pressure to act quickly or presenting themselves as authoritative figures.

Data breaches can have consequences for individuals

South said cybercriminals have historically targeted organizations because successful attacks can provide access to large amounts of information and potentially greater financial returns.

While companies have increasingly invested in cybersecurity measures, consumers may remain exposed when their information is held by an organization that suffers a breach. The resulting data can be circulated among malicious actors and used in attempts to defraud individuals.

South pointed to a cyberattack on a school board as an example of how an incident affecting an institution can have consequences for families. Parents may have shared credit card information and other personal details when paying for school lunches, trips or other school-related services.

Information collected for legitimate purposes can therefore become a source of exposure if the organization holding it is compromised.

South said the implications may not be immediately obvious to consumers. News of a large breach can seem distant until individuals realize that the affected organization held their own information.

The subsequent use of stolen data can also make it harder for consumers to distinguish legitimate communications from fraudulent ones, particularly when scammers use information that makes their approaches appear credible.

Urgency is a warning sign

Beyond the volume of information available to criminals, South highlighted the psychological tactics used in scams. Fraudsters may try to convince a victim that an account is about to be frozen, that immediate action is required to prevent a loss, or that sensitive information must be provided without delay.

Such tactics can undermine a person's judgement by encouraging them to respond before verifying the source of a request.

“One of the most important things you’ll find, and it’s pretty uniform when somebody is unfortunately the target or partway through a fraud event, is that the bad actors always try to create a sense of urgency,” South said.

Read more: Brokers should stop asking clients if they use AI and start asking how, CFC exec says

The pressure to act quickly can be particularly effective when a person is unsure how to assess a message or does not feel confident identifying a scam. A communication that appears to come from an authority or trusted organization may further encourage the recipient to comply.

South said consumers should approach unexpected requests with caution rather than assuming that an urgent message is legitimate. This does not mean avoiding online activity altogether, but it does mean taking time to verify requests before sharing information or taking action.

His advice is to apply a healthy level of skepticism to unfamiliar communications, particularly those that demand an immediate response.

“It's not to say you should live in fear or anything like that, but treat everything with a bit of skepticism,” South said.

Simple precautions remain important

South said consumers can reduce their exposure by adopting basic security practices across their online accounts and devices.

Using different passwords for different accounts is one important measure. Reusing the same credentials can leave multiple accounts exposed if one set of login details is compromised. Consumers should also enable two-factor authentication wherever it is available, adding another layer of protection beyond a password.

When shopping online, South recommended sticking to websites consumers know and trust and paying attention to unexpected redirects. Although legitimate payment processes can involve moving between websites, repeated or unfamiliar redirects may be a reason to stop and check that the destination is genuine.

Consumers should also avoid relying on easily guessed passwords based on names, children's names or dates of birth.

South said these precautions are straightforward, but they can help reduce the likelihood of falling victim to common attacks. The aim is not to eliminate every possible risk, but to make it harder for criminals to gain access to accounts or persuade people to disclose sensitive information.

Related Stories
Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB CA.