What happened: A BC property owner collected over $1 million in insurance proceeds for fire restoration, then refused to pay the contractor who did the work.
Who’s involved: Canstar Restorations Limited Partnership, MBW Canada Holding Inc., and Gore Mutual Insurance Company.
What’s at stake: $1,038,549.15 in unpaid invoices, plus interest at 24% a year.
Why it matters: Insurance proceeds earmarked for a contractor through a work authorization create a binding payment obligation - intercepting them is a breach.
Where it stands: Appeal dismissed. MBW’s counterclaim for defective work remains live.
Gore Mutual paid out more than $1 million after a fire severely damaged a commercial building. The property owner pocketed the lot.
A BC Court of Appeal panel has unanimously upheld a judgment ordering MBW Canada Holding Inc. to pay Canstar Restorations Limited Partnership $1,038,549.15 in unpaid invoices - plus interest at 24% a year. The decision came down on November 18, 2026.
The fire hit MBW’s commercial premises in Maple Ridge on December 31, 2020. Canstar, a restoration company, was called in by Gore Mutual Insurance Company’s adjuster to handle emergency repairs. Work started within days. MBW signed a one-page work authorization on January 7, 2021.
The deal was simple. Canstar would carry out emergency and environmental services as directed by the adjuster. Any insurance cheques would be endorsed by MBW to Canstar. Payment was due within 30 days of each invoice.
Gore Mutual paid MBW the full amount of Canstar’s invoices after an engineering consultant audited them. MBW kept the money.
Canstar sued to recover the funds. At a summary trial - a faster process where the judge decides based on written evidence rather than a full hearing - MBW argued Canstar had gone beyond the scope of the contract, done unnecessary work, breached laws, and caused damage. The trial judge found most of these arguments had no evidence behind them, noting MBW’s owner had credibility concerns, with submissions “contradicted by the evidentiary record or made without any evidentiary basis.”
An expert report MBW tried to rely on was thrown out. The author’s qualifications were not set out, the report did not follow court rules, and its conclusions appeared to advocate for MBW rather than offer independent analysis.
MBW appealed on a single ground: that the case should not have been decided by summary trial. It argued the judge overlooked its claim that any damages for defective work should be subtracted from what it owed Canstar, and gave too little weight to its argument that the work was poor.
The Court of Appeal disagreed. Chief Justice Marchand found the trial judge applied the correct legal principles and reasonably concluded the case was straightforward enough to decide without a full trial. The court pointed out that MBW had never actually raised the subtraction argument at trial and had produced no evidence to support it.
MBW’s separate claim that Canstar’s work was defective remains alive. But the $1,038,549.15 must be paid.
For claims professionals and adjusters, the case drives home a practical point: when a work authorization directs insurance proceeds to a contractor, the insured cannot simply sit on the funds - even while disputing the quality of the work.
The allegations in MBW’s counterclaim have not been tested at trial. The appeal addressed only whether the payment claim was properly decided on a summary basis. No court has ruled on MBW’s claims of defective work.