Artificial intelligence is giving independent brokerages an alternative to selling to larger groups, because the technology that once pushed small firms toward consolidation is now cheaper and more accessible, according to Andrew Nguyen (pictured), co-founder and chief operating officer at Boardwalk Insurance.
Access to better technology and centralized support has long been one of the reasons smaller brokerages joined larger groups. Nguyen said AI is changing that.
Read more: AI could leave insurers with weaker pricing models exposed to adverse selection
“Smaller brokerages had a hard time in the past really competing because technology was very expensive, but now knowledge and technology is becoming cheaper and more accessible to a lot of these smaller independent brokers,” he told Insurance Business.
Larger brokerages and consolidators have access to many of the same AI tools, Nguyen said, but rolling them out across a large organization takes time, particularly when new tools need to be integrated across multiple systems and teams.
That gives independents room to move, Nguyen said.
“They don’t have to essentially join a larger brokerage to have access to technology anymore,” he said.
Instead, independents can use AI to scale and grow their business on their own terms, Nguyen said.
The traditional model ties a brokerage’s growth to its headcount, Nguyen said. As client numbers and servicing demands grow, a brokerage often needs to add account managers to support and service that business. By cutting manual data entry and rekeying, AI can help brokerages grow their book without increasing support staff at the same rate, which he said is “giving optionality to independent brokerages.”
Boardwalk has seen that in its own submission work, Nguyen said. When a client’s information is complete, preparing a submission takes about 10 minutes on average, compared with about two hours previously, based on an internal measurement covering 50 submissions. AI reduces manual rekeying, and brokers still review and verify the submission.
“We’ve reduced the submission prep process from pretty much hours to minutes,” he said.
The time saved goes back to brokers for work that matters more, Nguyen said, including verifying the client’s information, identifying gaps in coverage, flagging limits that are not sufficient and spotting issues with a client’s current policy. Those are the tasks brokers should be good at and should be spending time on, he said.
The added capacity can also change how much business each person can handle. Boardwalk aims for about $3 million in annual premium per account manager, with the target varying by account mix, complexity and servicing requirements, Nguyen said.
That capacity opens room for upselling and cross-selling, Nguyen said, and allows staff to spend time quoting and writing new business when it comes in, rounding out a client’s coverage along the way.
“It really helps us write more business,” he said.
The financial benefits of AI will not show up evenly across the industry, Nguyen said, with results depending on how effectively the technology is built into a brokerage’s workflow.
Effective adoption will be a major factor, Nguyen said. For AI to deliver any meaningful financial uplift, “it needs to be embedded, and it needs to be built from the culture of the company,” he said. Nguyen added that brokerages that build AI into their operations effectively may see financial benefits sooner.
One early effect may show up in hiring, Nguyen said. Brokerages may start looking for account managers with deeper knowledge rather than technical service staff whose work is largely manual data entry, and demand for that second role is likely to shrink.
Read more: This brokerage let AI answer every call. It lasted four days
“We’re seeing that already at our brokerage,” he said. Some junior staff Boardwalk hired are moving into account manager roles because AI is reducing the rekeying of information.
He expects that shift to become more visible across the industry in 2027, because AI is already very capable of reducing the manual rekeying of information. Smaller brokerages that can adapt their workflows quickly may see benefits sooner, Nguyen said. Results will also depend on how each brokerage uses the technology, and the different AI models available can affect both accuracy and profitability, he said.
“It depends on how people use AI,” Nguyen said.
“I think it’s going to be fairly uneven in 2027 because the technology is still fairly new,” he added.