Alberta Care-First legislation passes as launch date looms

Injured drivers lose tort access as a market already shedding carriers prepares to reset
Alberta Care-First legislation passes as launch date looms
MOTOR & FLEET
By Roxanne San Jose
Nov 19, 2026

The Alberta government introduced Bill 41, the Financial Statutes Amendment Act, 2026 (No. 2), on November 17 – the final piece of legislation needed to bring the province’s Care-First auto insurance system into force on January 1, 2027. The omnibus bill amends seven pieces of existing legislation, completing a reform process that began in 2023 when a government-imposed rate freeze pushed Alberta’s auto market into sustained financial losses.

Under Care-First, injured drivers will no longer be able to sue the at-fault party for most losses. Benefits – covering medical care, rehabilitation, income replacement, and cash awards of up to $306,000 for serious injuries – are paid directly by the driver’s own insurer, regardless of fault. Disputes over those benefits go to a new Alberta Automobile Care-First Tribunal rather than the civil courts.

Alberta Finance Minister Jason Nixon confirmed at the time of tabling that “much of Care-First is already implemented,” with Bill 41 covering the final statutory amendments. The government has indicated it will conduct an 18-month review of the model after launch.

Read more: Care-First pricing hits Alberta renewal notices from November 1

A market under prolonged strain

The legislation lands after years of financial deterioration across Alberta’s private passenger auto market. According to the Alberta Superintendent of Insurance’s 2024 annual report, insurers paid out 18% more in claims and expenses than they collected in premiums – a combined industry loss of more than $1.2 billion. Of the province’s auto carriers, 35 recorded a financial loss that year.

That pressure has shrunk the market. Sonnet, Aviva Direct, Zenith, and CUMIS are among the carriers that exited or significantly reduced operations in Alberta between 2023 and 2026, citing unsustainable claims costs under government-capped rates. The province has had rate interventions in place, in some form, for seven of the past 10 years.

Third-party liability costs – primarily legal and litigation expenses – account for approximately 58% of what drivers pay in premiums, according to the Insurance Bureau of Canada (IBC), which argues that removing tort access from most claims is the most direct route to reducing that cost base.

The Alberta Civil Trial Lawyers Association (ACTLA), which represents more than 350 lawyers and law firms across the province, disputes that position. ACTLA has consistently argued that severe weather events – including the 2024 Calgary hailstorm and the Jasper wildfire – are the primary cost drivers recorded in the Superintendent’s report, not bodily injury litigation. The association has also raised access-to-justice concerns, warning that people with serious long-term injuries will be unable to pursue full compensation under a no-fault model.

Read more: IBC and trial lawyers clash over Alberta’s rising premiums

Projected savings remain a moving target

The savings figure has shifted across the reform’s timeline. Premier Danielle Smith cited savings of up to $400 annually at the system’s original announcement. By August 2026, IBC was citing a projection of $260 per year. The IBC’s November 17 statement placed the figure at $300. CBC reported in August 2026 that Alberta Finance acknowledged the original $400 estimate was based on 2023 data, and that subsequent cost pressures – including hail losses, vehicle theft, and broader claims inflation – had affected the modelling. The government stated it would undertake additional actuarial analysis ahead of the January launch.

To accompany the January launch, the government introduced a companion rate cap: average rate increases for Care-First policies are capped at 5% across each insurer’s overall customer base, with individual premiums capped at 10% per renewal.

Renewal season, coverage questions

The Insurance Brokers Association of Alberta (IBAA), which represents more than 5,300 brokers across the province, expressed support for the reform direction while flagging affordability risks. In a July 2025 statement, the association said it was “concerned that Alberta will end up having the most expensive care-based model of any jurisdiction in Canada,” given that the new system retains some court access – a feature it argued would continue to drive costs upward unless addressed.

Renewal notices priced under Care-First began reaching Alberta drivers from November 1. For brokers, the practical shift starts there: clients who previously held standard tort-based private passenger auto policies will, from January 1, face a system where the right to sue for pain and suffering is effectively removed in most collisions. Exceptions apply to Criminal Code violations and serious Traffic Safety Act breaches.

Clients with high incomes, pre-existing injuries, or complex long-term recovery needs are where coverage gaps are most likely to surface. The Insurance Institute of Canada has published Care-First training for licensed Alberta brokers, with continuing education credits available.

Related Stories
Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB CA.