Trisura tops peers with sub-85% combined ratio in Q1

Surety expansion and a sharper capital structure position the carrier among the most profitable specialty underwriters

Trisura tops peers with sub-85% combined ratio in Q1

Insurance News

By Kenneth Araullo

Trisura Group reported first-quarter 2026 operating net income of $37.9 million, or $0.78 per share, as the specialty insurance carrier posted double-digit revenue growth and finalised its largest capital raise to date.

Results outpaced analyst estimates even as several peers grapple with tightening underwriting margins.

Net insurance revenue climbed 12.1% to $193.6 million, while net income rose 29.0% year over year to $37.4 million. The combined ratio came in at 84.3%, compared with 82.7% a year earlier.

President and CEO David Clare described the quarter as "a strong start to the year," citing a 16.5% increase in net investment income alongside the underwriting result. Operating earnings per share topped the $0.76 average analyst estimate.

Surety lines posted net insurance revenue growth of 13.1%, which Clare attributed to scaling in the United States and continued expansion in Canada following gains achieved in 2025. Primary lines, identified by the company as carrying its highest underwriting margins, grew net insurance revenue by 11.4%.

Gross premiums written rose 6.1% overall, with primary lines advancing 12.9%. The loss ratio increased to 34.1% from 31.5%, a movement the company linked to a stronger comparable in US Programs in Q1 2025. The expense ratio improved slightly to 50.2% from 51.2%, and underwriting income edged up 2.2% to $30.5 million.

Trisura's sub-85% combined ratio places it among the more profitable specialty underwriters globally. Skyward Specialty Insurance Group reported a Q1 combined ratio of 89.5%, with gross written premiums up 9.9% to US$667.7 million.

Palomar Holdings disclosed a combined ratio of 84.5%, up sharply from 73.1% a year earlier, as its loss ratio jumped to 33.3%. Kinsale Capital, viewed by analysts as the E&S benchmark, continues to operate near 80%.

Capital structure

In March, Trisura closed a $200 million senior unsecured notes offering, which Clare called "an important milestone in the evolution of our capital structure." Proceeds refinanced existing indebtedness and reinforced the balance sheet, which now approaches $950 million.

The debt-to-capital ratio stood at 17.3% as of March 31, 2026, up from 10.7% a year earlier but below the company's internal target. Book value per share reached $19.98, a 16.4% increase from Q1 2025.

Trisura widened its US Surety footprint during the quarter, bringing its treasury-listed entity to 45 state licenses, with additions including Illinois, Pennsylvania, Georgia, Florida and Washington.

Research from Schauer Group pegs the 2026 contract surety market as healthy and stable, supported by Bipartisan Infrastructure Law and CHIPS Act activity, though previously reported data shows construction job openings cooled to a near-decade low last August.

The US wrote roughly US$9.3 billion in surety premiums in 2023, per earlier industry figures, with the global market projected to reach US$27 billion by 2030.

Trisura's expanded footprint sharpens its competitive stance against established leaders such as Travelers and The Hartford, while peers including Palomar are scaling through acquisitions like Gray Surety.

Related Stories

Keep up with the latest news and events

Join our mailing list, it’s free!