Multiple smaller catastrophes hitting different parts of the country at once can strain a claims operation more than a single major event, because they drain the pool of adjusters that firms rely on to scale up, according to Shelley Landry, vice president, Eastern Canada loss adjusting, at Crawford & Company.
Asked which scenario worries her most, Landry told Insurance Business, “I would say probably multiple little ones.”
Read more: Soft market is squeezing claims firms on fees, ClaimsPro president says
Crawford handles surges by moving adjusters between regions, she said.
“We rely on resources from other regions,” Landry said. “When a catastrophe happens in Ontario, we can pull folks in from Atlantic Canada, and vice versa.”
When several areas are hit at the same time, that option shrinks, she said. With a number of smaller events in multiple pockets, “that pool to draw from gets thinner and thinner as we go.”
This year’s storms and flooding in Ontario and Quebec put that capacity to the test, Landry said.
“It tested our ability to scale and adapt quickly,” she said.
Over about two and a half months, Crawford took on “an additional 2,300 claims across the country from one cat after another,” Landry said. Scaling up was only part of the challenge, she said, because the firm also had to keep delivering service at “a level that our clients expect,” particularly in a catastrophe, when “people want that immediate response or want that reassurance that everything is going to be okay.”
Having catastrophe plans in place with clients before an event makes the difference, she said. When one hits, “we can immediately implement the plan and start responding to their clients’ needs versus scrambling trying to figure out what we’re going to do and how we’re going to respond.”
Over her 25 years in the industry, the biggest change has been the speed and expectations of clients, Landry said. A quarter of a century ago, adjusters worked with paper and fax machines, and people understood that things took time.
“I think now with technology and the ability to contact people 24/7, people expect things to move much faster,” she said.
Claims have also become more complex as technology has evolved. “We’re seeing things like cyber, which 25 years ago was a foreign concept, and now it’s a big part of our business,” Landry said.
Technology is already handling much of the work on simpler files, she said, and on smaller, less complex claims, "the adjuster's role is eventually going to shift to more of an oversight role."
Larger and more complex losses are different, Landry said. There, “you need that technical expertise, you need that human touch, and you need that empathy.” Someone who has just lost their home wants a person to guide them through the process, not “here’s a link, upload everything,” she said.
AI will help by taking administrative work off adjusters’ desks, Landry said.
“I do think AI is going to allow adjusters to be more efficient and focus on the things that matter most,” she said.
Finding people to do that work is the toughest part of the job, Landry said.
“Our biggest challenge is recruitment and retention of staff,” she said. “It’s an industry issue.”
That pressure will build as the next wave of experienced adjusters retires over the next five to 10 years, she said. Crawford promotes heavily from within and works with recruitment agencies, but also develops its own talent. Its program brings in people with no claims or insurance experience, puts them through intensive training across different parts of the business, and then places them where their interests lie.
Whether they come from insurers or competitors, she said, the message Crawford hears most from new hires is that “they want the opportunity to grow.”
Landry said the most common misunderstanding among policyholders is that every claim will be handled the same way.
“Well, my neighbour had a claim, and their claim was settled in 48 hours,” she said, describing what insureds often tell adjusters.
Read more: AI wants to please you, and that’s a problem for claims, Allianz exec warns
Policies and loss circumstances differ, she said, and even the same policyholder can have very different experiences with a claim during a catastrophe and one outside of it.
Looking ahead, Landry said catastrophe preparedness and people will remain the two priorities, along with making sure Crawford has adjusters ready for emerging claim types such as cyber.
“I think we’re going to continue to see more natural catastrophes,” she said. “I anticipate 2027 will be a lot of the same.”