Data centres and battery energy storage systems are emerging as a new source of demand for environmental insurance in Canada, as a soft market and growing competition keep conditions favourable for buyers, according to Leo Lau, national environmental practice leader at Gallagher Canada.
These buyers know environmental insurance exists, he said, but the assets they are building carry exposures that traditional real estate doesn’t. Data centres keep large amounts of fuel on site so they can keep running during an outage, which may last hours or days.
“They require a lot of diesel fuel for their backup generators because if the power goes out, they need to keep this going,” Lau said. “So you have all this fuel that’s on site, and that could be a potential environmental exposure there.”
Read more: Cyber risk on renewable sites is a property risk too, Northbridge underwriter says
Battery storage sites carry a different risk, he said. Fires at these facilities are difficult to put out, and contaminated runoff from firefighting can reach neighbouring properties. Lau said he has seen claims where the owner was held responsible for cleanup on a third-party site. An environmental policy can help cover cleanup costs and natural resource damage claims in those cases, he said.
Lau said the broader environmental insurance market in Canada remains favourable for buyers.
“Currently in Canada, the insurance market is still quite soft in terms of the pricing,” he said.
“Capacity has generally stayed about the same,” Lau said, adding that buyers can generally get about $25 million in capacity. Some insurers have pulled back on particular risks, he said, sometimes because their head offices aren’t comfortable with them, but on excess layers, “every market wants a piece of it and they’re very eager to be part of that program.”
Higher-risk, complex sectors such as oil and gas and mining remain challenging for some markets, Lau said. If more energy projects and pipelines move ahead in Canada, some insurers may loosen their appetite, he said, though for now “it’s still more of a wait and see.”
New entrants are adding to the pressure on price, Lau said. Insurers that already write property or general liability are starting to add environmental cover.
“I think that’s where even more of a soft market drives that pricing because there’s so much more competition,” he said.
Lau, who has a background in environmental consulting and environmental & health and safety management as well as broking, said the most common mistake businesses make is waiting for an incident before thinking about their environmental exposures. Companies that identify their risks early can put processes in place to prevent and respond to incidents, he said, and that makes them more attractive to insurers.
Environmental insurers “love to see that proactive risk management,” Lau said, because it shows a client is working to reduce the chance of a catastrophic loss rather than relying on insurance alone.
In transactions involving contaminated or potentially contaminated sites, environmental risk can decide whether a deal goes ahead, Lau said. The problem usually comes down to a lack of information at the due diligence stage, such as missing Phase I or Phase II environmental site assessments or remediation reports.
“If the purchaser can’t quantify it or understand it, then the underwriter will definitely not understand it either,” he said.
In that case, underwriters are likely to add exclusions, which can put the deal in jeopardy, Lau said.
Read more: Renewable operators underestimate how long a loss keeps them offline
He compared a Phase I assessment to a home inspection. Consultants review records on how a site has historically been used and visit the property and its surroundings. If, for example, there is a gas station or heavy manufacturer next door, they may recommend a Phase II, which involves testing soil and groundwater to see whether contamination is present, spreading from the site or coming onto it.
A known, contained problem is often manageable, Lau said. Contamination that has moved off-site is different, because the cost of third-party liability is unknown.
“I think that’s what makes people nervous,” he said.
Insurers will likely exclude that exposure, Lau said, leaving the buyer to decide whether to take on the unknown liability themselves. “In most cases, it’s no,” he said.
When the reports are clean, brokers can share them with underwriters, who may then be confident enough to cover pre-existing conditions, Lau said. If contamination that nobody knew about is later discovered, the policy can respond, as long as it carries no exclusion for it.
Large, sophisticated real estate firms usually have these processes in place, he said, but many buyers aren’t as aware of the risks. That makes early advice essential, from environmental consultants and legal counsel to brokers and underwriters.
“It’s really important to have the right specialists from the beginning,” Lau said.