Better data and rising client demands are redrawing specialty lines

Relation Insurance’s Doug Turk on the two forces reshaping how specialty risks are priced and placed
Better data and rising client demands are redrawing specialty lines
EXCESS AND SURPLUS
By Mark Rosanes
Nov 19, 2026

The US surplus lines market hit a record $143.3 billion in direct premium written in 2025, according to AM Best. That was its eighth straight year of double-digit growth. More complex risks are flowing into the specialty market, and the demands on brokers have grown with them.

Doug Turk (pictured), president of specialty at Relation Insurance, identifies two forces driving this shift. In this article, he covers what those forces are and how to tell when a risk belongs in specialty. He also points to where the market’s biggest opportunities are right now.

Data and demand reshape specialty lines

Turk points to two forces changing the specialty insurance market. First, better data is giving carriers a sharper view of risk. It is uncovering underwriting factors that simply did not exist before. At the same time, clients are raising the bar on what they expect from their coverage.

“Look at how aviation operational data is now driving better underwriting decisions and how it creates better client outcomes,” Turk said. “This data reveals additional factors that directly relate to risk and underwriting that had not been available before.

“Clients are demanding policies that are tailored to their risk profiles and address their specific balance-sheet exposures and cost of capital models.”

Cyber shows what happens when both forces converge in a single line, Turk notes. As data has become more accessible in that market, underwriting and coverage decisions have had to keep pace with the risk itself.

“Cyber has always been on the leading edge of blending risk mitigation and risk transfer due to the rapidly evolving nature of technology and risk identification,” he said.

“Brokers have to be smart about what data and information are available and how they impact client risk and underwriting.”

Three signals a risk belongs in specialty

Knowing when to move a risk out of standard markets requires more than instinct. Turk offers a three-part test. The risk likely belongs in specialty when all three elements are present.

The first element is a clearly defined customer segment, such as film producers. The second is the existence of specialist brokers who have already built practices around that segment. The third is a set of markets that specifically write for that narrow risk category.

“Together, these three elements address specific client needs that otherwise cannot be served,” Turk said.

The framework works as a diagnostic. A film producer walking in with a standard commercial account may look like a routine renewal. But entertainment insurance specialists exist, specific markets write that exposure, and the customer segment is well defined. All three markers are present. The standard market conversation is probably the wrong one.

Losing talent means losing the practice

The disruption Turk describes in the specialty insurance market is not coming from technology or shifting market conditions. It is coming from talent.

Specialty brokers are not generalists. Turk argues that these individuals choose specific industries, products, or programs and build their professional reputation around that narrow focus. That expertise is what both carriers and clients buy into when they select a broker.

“The key is always the broking talent," he said. "These individuals have chosen to focus their careers in specific industries, products or programs and, as a result, are the most important factor in building a practice.”

That reputation is also portable. The relationships built around that expertise tend to follow when a specialty broker leaves. Markets that placed business with the firm because of a specific individual have no reason to stay. Clients who chose the firm for the same reason face the same calculation.

“If a company does not recognize and reward these people for their expertise, they can easily leave, with clients and markets following,” Turk said.

Policy terms that follow the risk

The fixed-period policy is the standard. Turk argues it is also the limitation.

“One opportunity is developing policy terms based on risk profiles rather than fixed periods of time,” he said. “Specifically, this means having the ability to rate and underwrite a specific risk when risk mitigation improves or the underlying risk profile changes.”

The model is iterative by design. The policy terms move with the risk as mitigation efforts improve and the underlying risk profile changes. The same data driving sharper underwriting in aviation or cyber applies equally here.

“A continuous improvement model that reflects reductions in risk can benefit all parties,” Turk said.

He draws a parallel to social media, where pattern recognition identifies consumption trends across large user bases. The same logic applies to an insurance portfolio. Data across a broad book can surface risk trends that no single account view would reveal.

“Pattern recognition can be applied across a large portfolio to quickly identify risk trends and mitigation opportunities,” Turk said.

Related Stories
Free newsletter

We'll keep you up-to-date with the latest breaking news, cutting edge opinion, and expert analysis affecting both your business and the industry as whole.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up - to - date with the world of Insurance. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from IB US.